Article

Hi-HO SILVER (AND GOLD): ‘THE SHEFFIELD SHUFFLER’ RIDES AGAIN

0 0 votes
Article Rating

By DAN VALENTI

PLANET VALENTI News and Commentary

(FORTRESS OF SOLITUDE, MONDAY, NOV. 10, 2014) — Was city money used to fund William Monterosso‘s Golden Parachute (said to be in the $150,000 range) following his disgraceful ouster at Berkshire Works? No said Pittsfield’s personnel director. Yes, the state shot back.

Both statements cannot be true. At best, someone is showing an egregious lack of knowledge. At worst, someone is lying. If the latter, one piece of advice — Lying is best done Big, and ’tis better to be an honest liar than one who ends up fooling everyone but himself.

C’mon down, John DeAngelo, a.k.a., “The Sheffield Shuffler” (TSS). He is not big. He cannot fool himself. No one can.

‘That Walking Embarrassment’

DeAngelo was smoked out of the steaming shitpile by Phil Demers of The Berkshire Eagle in two recent enterprise articles. It was THE PLANET that put The Shuffler in the steam in the first place with our breaking coverage of the scandal involving the walking “embarrassment” that formerly headed BW. “Embarrassment” is not THE PLANET’s word. It was the label BW’s HR director placed upon Monterosso.

Pittsfield mayor Dan Bianchi‘s initial reaction to the scandal was to sweep the mess under the rug. That woeful strategy worked until we got wind of the troubles. THE PLANET’s reportage whisked the rug out from under the mayor, his faired-haired boy from Crackerland, and DeAngelo. Toppled, all.

Demers’ coverage confirmed every important fact in the case first revealed by THE PLANET. Demers’ follow-up story illustrates how web-based journalism, with its ability to turn on dropped dimes, can work with the stodginess of traditional print journalism for the public good.

On the Monterosso story, THE PLANET made the initial discovery, mapped it, and sent back the dispatches from the front. The Eagle followed up by sending its man into the wilderness for detailed cartography. THE PLANET identified the wounds to the public trust, did triage on the body politick, stemmed the bleeding, and performed meatball surgery. The Eagle then did the fine stitching. THE PLANET created the design and drew the outline. The Eagle colored the drawing.

——– 000 ——–

‘I Can’t Really Disclose Anything’

When THE PLANET confronted DeAngelo face-to-face in his office, he clammed up faster than Ozzie Nelson when Harriet grilled him about the “night before.” Similarly, when Demers tried to get the details about the Berkshire Works scandal, TSS hid in milksop style that echoes nicely that of his boss.

From Demers’ story:

Under questioning by The Eagle, DeAngelo declined to respond to questions about Monterosso’s salary, the total amount he was paid after April 9 and by whom.

“I really can’t disclose anything regarding his tenure over there,” DeAngelo said.

Regarding the Golden Parachute Bianchi approved for his disgraced buddy (a minimum of $30,672 but much more likely $150,000), DeAngelo told Demers that state and federal dollars were used and that Pittsfield wasn’t out a penny. The “monies pass through the city[,] but that’s as far as it goes,” The Shuffler said.

Demers then checked with Ann Dufresne, communication director for the state Executive Office of Labor and Workforce Development. She strongly disputed The Shuffler’s statement:

Again, we go to Demers’ story:

Dufresne told The Eagle that the state made sure that no state or federal funds went to pay Monterosso’s separation package.

The executive director’s salary normally is comprised of state and federal funds, so according to Dufresne and other sources, the compensation had to come from an extraordinary source: BerkshireWorks discretionary funds. These funds typically pay for agency expenses not covered by state or federal funds.

Monterosso “was paid by the city,” Dufresne said. “He was neither appointed nor employed by the state. We had to verify that no federal or state funds were used in that settlement. The city paid it out of discretionary funds.”

So which person do you believe: Monterosso — a man whose abominable performance as HR director would, if this were a just world, propel his boss’ immediate demand for a resignation — or Dufresne, a highly regarded state official reviewing the situation with third-party neutrality?

BW’s Dan Collins: ‘The Lack of Communication and Disrespect from the City Has Been Appalling’

Demers’ report also had this nugget from Dan Collins, Berkshire Works’ HR director: “The lack of communication and disrespect from the city has been appalling.” Of Monterosso, Colling wrote an e-mail to DeAngelo on April 7, saying “He is an embarrassment to all of us.”

To date, neither Bianchi, DeAngelo, Kathy Degnan, nor anyone from the city has explained by Monterosso left (quit? fired? resigned?) barely three months into the job. Yet the mayor expects you, the public, to pay for his Golden Parachute (up to $150,000) and whatever damages will result from the charges that have been filed against Monterosso by Berkshire Works employees. There are at least two cases pending with the state and as many as eight, according to sources, which leads to a question: Why does DeAngelo still have a job?

Then we have this classic bit from The Pope of Transparency:

Throughout the ordeal, Pittsfield Mayor Daniel L. Bianchi, who appointed Monterosso to the job in late January, declined comment on the situation, deeming it “a personnel matter.”

Bianchi recently reiterated that stance.

“It was agreed that he would leave and he did,” Bianchi said.

Although the executive director’s position is funded by state and federal dollars, Pittsfield’s mayor is in charge of hiring for the position.

——– 000 ——–

Mary Jane and Joe Kapanski, once again Bianchi and his goons have thrown you under the bus.  He and his enablers — sycophants such as DeAngelo, Julia Sabourin, and Kathy Degnan — have taken city government and made of it a zero-sum game.

You get the “zero.”

They get the “sum.”

————————————————————————————

“The time to hesitate is through. No time to wallow in the mire. Try now. We can only lose, and our love become a funeral pyre.”The Doors, “Light My Fire,” (1967).

“OPEN THE WINDOW, AUNT MILLIE.”

LOVE TO ALL.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
37 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
dusty
dusty
9 years ago

I am impressed by Phil Demers work and I hope he does a lot more of it. The Eagle needs to let reporters report. For some newspapers its actually a job for reporters to report. So I hear.

The Eagle needs to stop letting city hall approve all copy. Grow some balls. Be a real newspaper and not an arm of the corruption that is Pittsfield government

They gave the newspaper a new face and now they need to give it a new body. Be the newspaper your customers want you to be not what the politicians want. Do not let high level Eagle employees wives work at city hall so that they are in fear of losing their jobs if the Eagle writes a negative story about dubious goings on at city hall.

More than anything else that could help get this city get off the corruption band wagon would be a newspaper that digs it out and puts names on its front pages for all to see. A newspaper like that would sell a lot of copy and make serious money. If only

Ron Kitterman
Ron Kitterman
9 years ago

I wonder if the $150 K paid to BW was in the bottom left hand drawer intended for $200K BCC astro turf money.

spagirl
spagirl
9 years ago

Why does DeAngelo still have a job. Why does Dan Bianchi still have a job. Degnan is as much a player. Atrocities across the board. Pittsfield Residents Standup. Shake this administration down. Demand it.

delussionist
delussionist
9 years ago

The two pictures below are seemingly identical. However, there are at least six differences. Can you spot them?

Picture #1:

Mayor Bianchi fires Veterans director Roseann Frieri. First suspended without pay and then fired without pay.

Then Mayor Bianchi fires RSVP director Deborah Sadowy Dargie without pay. Terminated after telling her personally she was doing a fine job and not to worry.

Picture #2:

Mayor Bianchi terminates William Moneroso as director of Berkshire Works after only 3 months on the job. At first suspended with full pay, then a full city taxpayer funded separation package worth over $150,000.00.

Rosaura
Rosaura
Reply to  delussionist
9 years ago

And don’t forget me Rosaura Román. After working for the city for almost 19 years and over 850 hrs of accrual sick time, my pay check was docket for 7 hrs because supposedly I didn’t call in. According to the legal team and HR the physical phone alone wasn’t enough proof of the phone call. I had to request the telephone records from the phone company. And guess what, I made the call, left the message but no one knows what happened to it. To this day, I have not received my day back.

EddieP
EddieP
Reply to  delussionist
9 years ago

The money saved from not paying out to picture #1 is used to make the payout in picture #2.The old rob Peter to pay Paul syndrome.
Sounds plausible..

Gatos
Gatos
Reply to  EddieP
9 years ago

Or robbing Pam to pay Paul. A little sexism?

dusty
dusty
Reply to  Gatos
9 years ago

I heard someone got the combination to the mayors safe, busted into it and took all the cash. So I don’t know how anyone is getting paid anything. But this poor mayor has been besieged by misfortune it seems. Wiley coyote was treated better by the road runner than this mayor is being treated by karma.

nostrodumbass
nostrodumbass
Reply to  dusty
9 years ago

It was probably a disgruntled underpaid city employee just paying himself one way or another.

Bill Sturgeon
Bill Sturgeon
9 years ago

It is my opinion, that the job of the City Solicitor is protect the City of Pittsfield and its citizens from legal hazards! The City Solicitor is “NOT” the Mayor’s private attorney hired to do his/her bidding.

The Human Resources Director’s job, in my opinion, is to insure that all of the laws and personnel regulations are followed. Additionally, the HRD should “NOT” let the Mayor do HR things that are not within the laws, personnel regulations and/or contractual agreements.

Just my opinions!

spagirl
spagirl
Reply to  Bill Sturgeon
9 years ago

I so agree with your opinions.

Cherrie
Cherrie
9 years ago

One thing has been clear not just in this case but in other dealings involving the mayor and his HR director: They deliberately muddle simple requests for information.

This has happened not only with The Eagle and Demers, not only with DV, but also the Gazette. Any request for public records in an area where the mayor is covering up something is first stifled.

This type of ‘leadership’ has made city government dysfunctional, a place where good employees are fearful and bad ones run loose.

spagirl
spagirl
Reply to  Cherrie
9 years ago

AND Broken Trust everywhere. CORRUPT!!!

Under Pressure
Under Pressure
9 years ago

The Bianchi Administration is digging its own grave with all this lockdown of public information policy.

The Bianchi-Sabourin-Degnan-DeAngelo-Mazzeo lockdown is building a history of records for future action against the city.

Sabourin’s involvement in violation of the open meeting laws in the trial of Terry Kinnas school committee snafu is now a matter of record.
The Berkshire Eagle’s request to the State for emails was granted by the State but denied by the city, in particular by DeAngelo. Now a matter of record.
The State has recently put Degnan on notice to release the documents to Barry or explain why you refuse to do so. Now a matter of record.
Barry has appealed to the State for the release of the documents. Now a matter of record.
Barry has filed a petition to the city for an exemption to city councilors not to be charged for copies of information pertaining to the running of the city. Now a matter of record.

A good lawyer would be able to put all this together in an actionable case against the city for not following the laws.

Bianchi may be successful in bringing down others along with himself in building up this history of records in foolishly supporting his lockdown of public information policies.

Knows the Truth
Knows the Truth
9 years ago

City of Pittsfield is the only employer that does not do background checks, references, or any other information collected by an applicant’s former employment. Continually attract retreads or employees that nobody wants…..

Ed McClelland
Ed McClelland
Reply to  Knows the Truth
9 years ago

Pittsfield Personnel Director, DeAngelo had the quintessential City qualifications; He was HR/finance director of a non profit, grant and endowment funded institution, that went broke when the money shuffling disssipated. He was acting CEO when it closed and became skilled at preverification and oblivion. And he doesn’t pay Pittsfield taxes. Perfect.

Jonathan Melle
Jonathan Melle
9 years ago

What about William Monterosso’s Attorney: Andrea Francesco Nuciforo Junior? What role did Nuciforo play in Monterosso’s 6-figure severance package? What was Nuciforo’s cut?
Nuciforo was mentioned in Phil Demers’ news articles. Nuciforo said the allegations against his client are “baseless”.
How come Nuciforo rules over Pittsfield politics decade after decade? No one elected him Mayor!

Joe Blow
Joe Blow
9 years ago

Now the school dept. is looking for new ways to get more of our loot. These tax and spend liberals are destroying our city, state and country.

http://www.berkshireeagle.com/local/ci_26902606/committee-weigh-law-allowing-pittsfield-city-council-increase

The City Council’s Ordinance and Rules Committee later this month will consider adopting a state law that would allow the council to increase a School Department budget.

The change would give school officials “the opportunity to appeal directly to the City Council” for additional spending, according to Councilor at large Churchill Cotton. Currently, the council can only decrease a school budget submitted by the mayor.

dusty
dusty
Reply to  Joe Blow
9 years ago

Are you kidding me? Whomever dragged this pork pile out in the open should be given the bag o dicks award for insensitivity. I am sure it was not Cotton or Yon initially but they need to understand that their job is to serve the people NOT the incompetent and dysfunctional administration.

The school system needs to stop buying buses they don’t need and schools that they don’t need and they won’t need to bleed the taxpayers into poverty. They are making a mockery of government. Why does Pittsfield have so many idiots that are attracted to public service????

nostrodumbass
nostrodumbass
Reply to  Joe Blow
9 years ago

You know when I first saw this, I thought same as you – not a good thing – right?

The way they are spinning it is the school committee is after more money.

However, take a look at at it.
First off, the mayor himself is against it.
That should send off some bells ringing.
He claims he is against it because it will cost taxpayers more money. NOT True.
He is agisnst it because it takes the power away from him and gives it to the school committee and the city council by super majority vote.
What could be more democratic than that?

As is stands, now, the mayor decides to increase the school budget, he and he alone. And did by over a million dollars. Increased it. So his arguement against it is hogwash.

At least the new way will go before the city council and get voted on and passed by super majority. Everyone in the city should favor this. They should demand this more democratic method instead of letting the mayor decide.

Linda
Linda
9 years ago

Greaet coverage DV. As one previous comment put it earlier you have singlehandedly made the Eagle more competitive. A friend who works for the city has an equally dreary opinion of Mr. DeAngelo’s professionalsm or lack of it.

As for giving council power to hike school dept budget, no, no a million times no. To my ward councilor, Mr. Connell: I urge youDO NOT vote for this. Sorry for typos done from my phone.

GMHeller
GMHeller
9 years ago

Mr. Valenti,

Please post a photo of William Monterosso and also John DeAngelo to accompany your expose.
It would help to know just who the actors are in these various dramas which result in public monies being expended unnecessarily.

Frank N Stien
Frank N Stien
Reply to  GMHeller
9 years ago

Dan post pictures of DeAngelo and Monteroso when Heller post a picture of himself.

Jonathan Melle
Jonathan Melle
9 years ago

Thousands of people have left Pittsfield over the years.
Thousands of jobs have been lost in Pittsfield, too.
There are more people on welfare in Pittsfield than have private sector living wage jobs.
Taxes are really high in Pittsfield with a shrinking tax base.
Pittsfield’s liabilities (or debts) are in the hundreds of millions of dollars.
Pittsfield wants to build a new high school with no way to pay for it.
Pittsfield politics is really corrupt.
Downtown Pittsfield is known as “Social Services Alley” by day, and is overran with crime, drugs, and gangs at night.
Pittsfield is a toxic waste dump full of cancer causing PCBs.
The Good Old Boy network of interrelated, multigenerational families rule Pittsfield politics with an iron fist.
Hundreds of school children choice out of Pittsfield public schools every year.
The list goes on and on.
The bottom line: Pittsfield sucks!

Charles Kronick Berkshire
Charles Kronick Berkshire
Reply to  Jonathan Melle
9 years ago

I just looked out the window. Nope. alls well, JM. The weather’s lovely, neighborhood is happy, no problems to report. Perhaps I’ll see you at the lake; going fishing.

Charles Kronick Berkshire
Charles Kronick Berkshire
9 years ago

The Demers article caps the package at $50,000. Where do you see another $100,000 hiding?

MrG1188
MrG1188
Reply to  Charles Kronick Berkshire
9 years ago

That’s not really the point Charles. It’s all a guess. Could be $30k, $50k or $150k couldn’t it? The point is that it was public, taxpayer money from the local town; not even the state or fed, even though municipal employees LIED about the source of that money, so we as the providers of the money have a right to know whether it was $30, 50, or 150k.

Spider
Spider
9 years ago

I am totally opposed to having our City Council be able to INCREASE any school budget. Most of the budgets that appear before the council are exorbitant and in many cases should be decreased.

amandaWell
amandaWell
9 years ago

Ain’t no fish in the Lake this time of year,s Charles.

Charles Kronick Berkshire
Charles Kronick Berkshire
Reply to  amandaWell
9 years ago

Never stopped me, Ma’am. I pulled in a nice size stump, and got a free lure no cost to me.

Scott
Scott
Reply to  Charles Kronick Berkshire
9 years ago

Good for you charles if one goes with the mind set on catching he’s already done himself a great disservice. For me just hearing the stream roll is satisfactory.

Charles Kronick Berkshire
Charles Kronick Berkshire
Reply to  Scott
9 years ago

Bingo. Caught a lovely sunset on Onota.

Jonathan Melle
Jonathan Melle
9 years ago

I heard Jack Welch is going to swim in Pittsfield’s Silver Lake tomorrow morning.

amandaWell
amandaWell
9 years ago

What are those sneaker fish hanging from the wires at the causeway?

Charles Kronick Berkshire
Charles Kronick Berkshire
Reply to  amandaWell
9 years ago

They aint no sneaker fish – some lucky fellow cut them out of the belly of a giant pike. Sneakers are quite resilient. Otherwise, the utility folk claimed the ornaments hanging there and raised the wires. Friendly of them.

All the same, Pittsfield is a fine place to live for those who know how to.

Scott
Scott
Reply to  Charles Kronick Berkshire
9 years ago

You’re right forget about the beacon, colonial and all of downtown. We’re surrounded by wilderness ripe with blackberries in August and an abundance of fresh air year round.