PENNY CANDY
BY DAN VALENTI
PLANET VALENTI NEWS AND COMMENTARY
(FORTRESS OF SOLITUDE, MONDAY NOV. 16, 2026) — Opening THE PLANET‘s bag of penny candy this morning, we discover a few items:
A Measurable War: Both the President and Vice President cited the war with Iran, notably higher gas prices, as a major factor in the onslaught wins by Democrats in the mid-term elections. Victory in this war, however, must be measured by one thing: Did it, has it, and will it prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons? If the answer is “yes,” than Trump’s actions will receive a favorable verdict from history. Unlike so many pseudo “wars” and the military adventurism of recent past, this one at least had a clear and measurable objective. It appears to have been achieved. As of yet, Israel hasn’t been nuked.
Come Together: One interesting and positive development of the Iran action is that it has forged greater unity in that part of the world. The latest example is pact signed in Istanbul by Turkey and Qatar. The two sides pledged to work together to prevent reigniting the war in the Gulf region. You’ll recall in August, Turney entered into similar defense agreements with Pakistan and Saudi Arabia.
Opportunity Knocks: The Kraft Group, the umbrella organization for New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft’s many companies, has run into major flack over its plan with Global Packaging Group to build a large data center in Sutton, a town of 9,300 in the Blackstone Valley of Worcester County. Could this be an opportunity for Pittsfield? The center needs a water supply, a large enough footprint, and rail transportation. The William Stanley Business Park has all three. Advice to Mayor Peter Marchetti: Contact the Kraft Group and express the city’s interest. It would mean jobs and a huge boost for the local economy, with billions in investment, most of it private capital.
No Censure: During the most recent meeting of the Pittsfield school committee (SC), the group aired a demand for censure filed by the United Educators of Pittsfield, the purpose of which, contrary to stated aims of UEP president James Hurley, was to silence and intimidate Ciara Batory. Seems Batory’s persistent questioning of administrative failures has gotten to both the UEP leadership and supt. Latifah Phillips. In the end, after SC members Sarah “Twenty Muil Team” and Kathy “Babbles” Yon squabbled with Batory, the group voted to take no action against her. Nonetheless, the point was made: “Play ball or else.” THE PLANET wonders if Batory will stick it out for the rest of her term. Is the agita worth it? We must add one note: Mayor Marchetti ran a good meeting.
Hurley Hurdles: “When you make a public statement, you speak as a member of the School Committee. As teachers, we cannot freely express everything we think on social media. If I said some of the things I would like to say, I would be fired. The First Amendment does not mean we can say anything we want without facing consequences. A censure is not intended to silence you, but rather to review your actions and point out conduct considered inappropriate.” Thus spake UEP president Jim Hurley, who apparently is a constitutional scholar of the highest order. Doesn’t mean he knows squat about the First Amendment, however. Two things: (1) He admits to holding views that would get him fired if freely expressed. That is an admission of retaliation as a tool of local government. (2) He equates First Amendment restrictions (yelling “Fire!” in a crowded nightclub) with the free expression of thought, in this case on social media. The two are nothing alike. THE PLANET offers a free tutorial to Mr. Hurley in the First Amendment, should he wish. Suggested donation: Priceless.
Outage: When and since Microsoft’s Outlook, Teams, and AI assistant Copilot crashed globally, the company has struggled to fix the problem, causing a worldwide disruption in business, pharmacies, law enforcement, and countless other companies and services that rely on Microsoft technology. Microsoft claims the unprecedented outage was not caused by cyberattack or, more malevolently, AI agents. It said the caboose crashed following “a recent network change” — which tells us nothing. THE PLANET know as well as you do that if it had been a rival AI going rouge, it wouldn’t be made public.
Riddle Us This: How are Mary Jane and Joe Kapanski like the “red shirts” seen in the opening teaser of the original Star Trek episodes? We shall look for your answers. Remember, not only do we know where all the bodies are buried, we buried a few ourselves (with apologies to our good friend Peter Lucas of the Boston Herald).
Bada bing, bada boom.
—————————————————————–
“Why bother? ‘Tis a question all of us must answer?” — Sir Donald Turpentine, Knight of the Bath.
“OPEN THE WINDOW, AUNT MILLIE.”
LOVE TO ALL.
Copyright (c) 2026 By Dan Valenti, PLANET VALENTI and EUROPOLIS MANAGEMENT. All rights reserved. The views and opinions expressed in the comment section or in the text other than those of PLANET VALENTI are not necessarily endorsed by the operators of this website. PLANET VALENTI assumes no responsibility for such views and opinions, and it reserves the right to remove or edit any comment, including but not limited to those that violate the website’s Rules of Conduct and its editorial policies. Those who leave comments own all the responsibilities that are or can be attached to those comments, be they rhetorical, semantic, or legal. Such commentators remain solely responsible for what they post and shall be and remain solely accountable for their words. PLANET VALENTI shall not be held responsible for the consequences that may result from any posted comment or outside opinion or commentary as provided in, but not limited to, Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act and this website’s terms of service. We serve as a marketplace of ideas, without prejudice and available to all. All users of this site — including readers, commentators, contributors, or anyone else — hereby agree to these conditions by virtue of this notice and their use of/participation in this site. When PLANET VALENTI ends with the words “The Usual Disclaimer,” that phrase shall be understood to refer to the full text of this disclaimer.











Ciara Batory is being made an example of for anyone who dares speak out against any school policies. This all started when a teacher wanted the emails of students and other contact info in case of emergencies. There is no emergency that a teacher would need to contact a student about. If school is cancelled that is made public knowledge in local media. Being able to privately communicate with a student via email is wrong and leads to bad things happening as we saw here in Pittsfield. Ciara was absolutely doing the right thing by speaking out against this.
November 16, 2026
Re: Ciara Batory versus the Ghost of Carmen
Hello blogger Dan Valenti,
Ciara Batory wants accountability in the face of all of the SECRECY in state and local government in Pittsfield politics. The one-Democratic-party system of political insiders runs on SECRECY from Boston to Pittsfield, Massachusetts.
She was blamed by city officials and a union boss for what other online social media posters wrote. Ergo: 2 + 2 = 5; The Twilight Zone; Kafkaesque; Up is down and down is Up.
The Pittsfield public school district and Superintendent’s Office is run by SECRECY with NO accountability. Ergo, parents are turning to the one Pittsfield School Committee Member named Ciara Batory for transparency and accountability so that there children won’t be fed to the wolves.
Pittsfield expects to raise 248,963,880 in FY2027. (That is, as always, tens of millions of dollars per fiscal year MORE than Pittsfield’s peer small cities such as Fitchburg and Westfield. Pittsfield has the 2nd highest commercial tax rate in Massachusetts; Holyoke is 1st).
NOTE: Earl and the 2-Pete’s Pittsfield politics pounds, pummels, pulverizes, punishes people’s purses!
Blogger Dan Valenti posted that the fictional Kapanski’s Pittsfield public school tax bill in Fiscal Year 2027 is estimated to be $130 million (when one includes all of the other budget costs that are hidden in the city side of the operating budget).
No wonder city officials and a union boss threatened to censure Ciara Batory. They had 130 million reasons to protect their “green” turf against any would-be losses to their bottom line.
The trade-off, of course, is that parents are powerless, and their children may be in harm’s way. It is clear that the Pittsfield city officials and a union boss do NOT care!
Similar to the federal government’s ongoing secrecy with the Epstein Files, Pittsfield refuses to release to the public the taxpayer-funded, 6-figure legal report that alleged serious wrong-doings, including, but not limited to, the alleged sexual exploitation of Pittsfield High School (PHS) students who were under the age of 18 by named adult staff members.
A while ago, I wrote to Governor Maura Healey to ask her to please investigate Pittsfield’s scandals, but her office sent me an email to let the local officials in Pittsfield handle it. It was NOT what I wanted her to decide, of course. I also read about the alleged and/or verified rapes of a woman (possibly other women) under the age of 18 by illegal immigrants in Massachusetts during her now close to 4-year tenure running the Commonwealth.
I believe that the career politicians from Boston to Pittsfield are more concerned about protecting their fiefdom(s) than protecting children.
PHS is my Alma Mater (Class of 1993); as well as blogger Dan Valenti’s Alma Mater. It is believed that the Ghost of BOYS Club Camp Counselor Carmen haunts the halls where today’s PHS students may still face similar perils as the then-BOYS did at Camp Russell many years ago when Carmen’s reputation became infamous in Pittsfield lore.
Best wishes,
Jon Melle
W
Sorry about the previous post, that’s what happens when your dog steps on your keyboard. LOL
Dan, I did see your original post about this School Committee meeting then it was taken down. Hope this crappy Administration didn’t try to sensor the Planet too. Nothing would suprise me.
I was totally mortified by the LYNCH MOB against Ciara Batory at the Scohol Meeting the other night! The whole rest of the committee sat there on their high horse blasting her and worse of all was Mayor Useless Lumpy sitting on the highest horse enjoying every minute of it! He totally disgust me, and I truly feel he is a woman hater.
I give Ciara Batory accolades for how she handled the assault. My heart was literally breaking for her. I had tears in my eyes and I don’t even know her. The attack sickened me and I can’t stop thinking about how she was basically assaulted. Thank goodness she asked to have it publicized, imagine how it would have been behind closed doors.
What did Ciara do wrong? She did her job. It’s not her fault that taxpayers reach out to her, she is the only one that cares and responds. So she get blasted for it. How many times did Ciara ask the other members why taxpayers don’t contact them and they sat their like Lumpy’s lumps on a log. Were they told not to answer?
Heather McNeice in her motherly voice toots her snobby nose about how great of a teacher she is…then why did she leave PPS and go to Lenox? Tired of her openly kissing Mayor Lumpy’s ASS. It’s grossly pathetic.
Sarah Mull acts like a mule, nothing but a female jackass. What has she done during her term, usually everyone has to explain things a couple times to her before she comprehends. There was no need for her to attack Ciara. It sounded like Ciara had reached out to her previously and what does Sarah do but turn on Ciara. Maybe Sarah should watch her sister Elizabeth Banks on television and view the kindness she puts out to complete strangers.
How about the way Carolyn Barry just backs away from the table with her glasses on her nose and does not join in. She stated that she admired Ciara for her guts, I don’t remember the exact verbiage, but my question for Carolyn is where are your guts you promised taxpayers. Why don’t you stand up for Ciara? What are you afraid of Carolyn? Is it Mayor Lumpy?
Mayor Lumpy why does it takes over almost a year and a half for these committee members to attend a training session? Did you also notice that when Ciara asked the others if they had attended the training, once again no one answered? Something is very wrong with this scenario. Yet you want to give these folks a big raise. Is that why they are going along with you? Complete dysfunction.
All in all, you look at the Pittsfield School department losing over 600 children to out schooling to neighboring school systems, and by the way the kids are flourishing. Many of these parents have transfered their child due to bullying in the Pittsfield school system. Well what the HELL do you think the Mayor and other School Committee members and Union did to Ciara the other night. That whole one and half hour was PURE bullying. Did this bully action make Lumpy, Heather, Sarah, Carolyn and Dan feel really important? As far as I am concerned they are despicable and will never get my vote again.
M&B
The post was taken down at the request of one of the key sources. In addition, it was premature. No censure involved.
Dan should receive his own award the Orbit. If anyone understood what Lady Boots was pontificating he definitely deserves the Award. Any One that wants to fuck up their hearing by translating into their brain what Bootshad to say deserves the award.
I thought the same thing with the Data Center would put Pittsfield back on the map for years to come. Could negotiate a deal that would bring into the future for sure.