Article

HEALTH INSURANCE SWITCH, ‘100GATE’, AND THE MAYOR’s DICTATORIAL POWER GRAB: A COUNCIL AGENDA & ANTI-DEMOCRACY

0 0 votes
Article Rating

By DAN VALENTI

PLANET VALENTI News and Commentary

(FORTRESS OF SOLITUDE, TUESDAY, OCT. 14, 2014) — Tonight, our Right Honorable Good Friends on the Pittsfield city council gather. Hip boots, gas masks, and clothes pins have been ordered.

Three of the mayor’s favorite pet projects are up for … what? Discussion, debate, and deliberation — words that would “normally” apply to a legislative meeting where the chief executive is merely an invited guest — don’t cover it. Those activities, indicative of healthy politics, do not occur in Pittsfield. “Coronation,” “done deals,” and “rubber stamping” more closely suggest the “flavor and feel” of what passes for representative government in The Shire City.

——– 000 ——–

AGENDA ITEM #5“A communication from [the mayor] submitting a presentation from Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts outlining the new healthcare plans and financial comparison between GIC and Blue Cross Blue Shield.”

The mayor and Brendan Sheran, United Educators of Pittsfield chief, engineered this switch from the cost-savings  GIC insurance pool to the more expensive BCBS coverage. The mayor will present the plan as cost effective, citing first-year rates. As THE PLANET has revealed, however, the introductory rates are off the table in year two, when the premiums shall go up, Up, UP.

The mayor delivered this coup even after the Pittsfield Employees Commisstion, representing all city unions, unanimously rejected the plan 15-0 on Sept. 2. In the second vote (Sept. 25), union representatives again voted against the switch, 11-4. The only problem was Sheran’s vote was worth more than 35% of the total.

A city hall source alleges Sheran “was promised something for delivering his vote.” Also, it has been suggested that Gerald Miller, representative of the retirees, “handed his vote to the UEP rep due to his wife passing.” If he also had Miller’s 10.1% weighted vote, this one man controlled almost half the vote.

Thus, in two elections, the unions rejected the switch 26-4. The measure passed because of the weighted vote. In other times and towns, this would be scandalous. In 2014 Pittsfield, it’s business as usual.

Longterm cost to taxpayers: Uncounted millions of dollars.

——– 000 ——–

AGENDA ITEM #7 — “A communication from [the mayor] submitting a response to a petition filed by Councilor Clairmont on August 12, 2014.”

This innocuous sentence refers to 100gate, another stink bomb from the corner office. As with the insurance switch, it was done without council knowledge or approval — a unilateral action that spoke well of arrogance, conceit, self-interest, and self-importance.

The item references councilor-at-large Barry Clairmont’s questions for the mayor regarding 100gate. The mayor’s responses can be read in the council packet attached to the online agenda. The mayor’s cover letter says he “will be available, if needed.” One must be grateful for small blessings, and we applaud the mayor’s availability. Clairmont’s performance with the mayor should make for good political theater, but more interesting to THE PLANET will be the push-back, if any, the mayor receives from the other 10 councilors. Will they continue their rubber-stamping acquiescence, or will they find a voice with which to actually represent We The People?

The mayor’s responses to Clairmont’s questions range from factual to fictional. To the question of “the purpose for moving these departments out of City Hall,” the mayor touts the advantages of “a central location” to expedite the permitting process.” The example the mayor then uses to tout “one stop shopping” is, of all things, Hollywood. We kid you not. The mayor writes:

“For example, if a person comes to the City to pull a permit to film a movie, it is extremely complicated. Due to the complex nature of permitting, The Berkshire Film Collaborative often becomes involved. … Obtaining a movie permit within Pittsfield requires multiple steps and extended wait time that is difficult for film producers who work outside the area.” 

“For example, if a person comes to the City to pull a permit to film a movie …” Yeah, like that happens every day. This fantastical prose speaks of the defensiveness and desperation involved in defending a defenseless idea.

Many of the mayor’s responses do not address the question asked, a typical political dodge. Others are suspiciously nuanced. A huge volume of ancillary material seems to have no other purpose than to obfuscate and fluff up.

Q: “What was the response from the State Ethics Commission regarding the potential conflict of interest relating to your private business [Global energy] being located in the same building in which you are now entering into a government lease agreement?”

A: “Mayor Bianchi contacted the State Ethics Commission [DATE NOT GIVEN]. The Commission determined that there did not appear to be any direct conflict of interest [NOTE THE QUALIFIERS AND THE WIGGLE ROOM THEY ALLOW]. They stated that if the Mayor wished, he could submit a full disclosure form to the City Clerk. The disclosure form was submitted to the City Clerk on September 11, 2014 [THE PLANET HAS REQUESTED A COPY OF THAT DISCLOSURE].

——– 000 ——–

AGENDA ITEM #16“A public hearing on an Administrative Order authorizing the City of Pittsfield to establish the appointing authority for non-department head employees.”

This is a flat-out power grab by the mayor. In plain English, this is about giving the mayor absolute appointing authority for nearly all city employees. If the mayor’s “Administrative Order” passes, he alone shall appoint “all positions” in the —

— Accounting Department

— Building Department

— City Clerk’s Office

— Department of Community Development

— Data Processing Center

— Department of Cultural Development

— Department of Public Utilities

— Department of Public Services

— Fire Department

— Maintenance Department

— MIS (IT) Department

— All police civilians

— All police officers

— Office of Tax Collector

— Department of Finance/Treasurer

— Veteran’s Department

— Emergency Management Department

— Mayor’s Office

— Personnel Department

— Purchasing Department

— Registrar of Voters

— Solicitor’s Office

— Traffic Supervisors

——– 000 ——–

These dictatorial appointments would be without review or oversight. You can see the obvious problem. What’s to prevent the mayor from hiring hacks, loyalists, friends, and family? We have already the mayor’s predilection toward self-interest and against the best interests citizens, taxpayers, The Little Guy, and Mary Jane and Joe Kapanski. Upon what reasonable basis, therefore, is there to expect this selfish tendency to dissipate into an attitude more friendly to his constituents?

Little to none.

——– 000 ——–

The council meeting begins tonight at 7 p.m. at city hall.

——————————————————————————————

“Summertime was nearly over. Blue Italian sky above. I said, “Lady, I’m a rover. Can you spare a sweet word of love?”Bing Crosby, “Isle of Capri,” (1955).

“OPEN THE WINDOW, AUNT MILLIE.”

LOVE TO ALL.

 

 

0 0 votes
Article Rating
24 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
dusty
dusty
9 years ago

Once again, if you are raising children in Pittsfield, and you truly love them, make them aware that it is a big country they live in and there are many better places to live than Pittsfield, Massachusetts. In Pittsfield your opportunities are proportionally limited to the number of power connections you have with the political fiefdom.

Go west young man, go west.

Larry Bird?
Larry Bird?
Reply to  dusty
9 years ago

Also remember if you work very hard and have success in the Public sector a small number of loud voices will diminish your success by claiming you obtained it through relationships with the political fiefdom.

Thus, I second that by saying if you have kids remind them again there are much better places to live than Pittsfield, MA.

Ron kitterman
Ron kitterman
9 years ago

Unbelievable it use to be government was subservient to the people, now the people are subservient to the government. Civil Service although not the best system is a lot better than appointing only friends of the politically connected and turning the power of appointments over to the Mayor.

Bill Sturgeon
Bill Sturgeon
9 years ago

Ron:
“They” have let the Civil Service System fall into its current condition. When it (Civil Service) was at the top of its game is insured fairness and equality. Perhaps, that why it was permitted or pushed into disrepair.

Tim Bartini
Tim Bartini
Reply to  Bill Sturgeon
9 years ago

Bill your right Civil Service was purposely underfunded and understaffed so that the mayors and town managers could get total authority over all personnel. Total abuse of power. Dan. By the way Gerald Millers name is Gerard or Jerry. Jerry Miller is his own man and he has the retirees best interest The insurance change will benifit most if not all of the retirees. The Firefighters voted NO mainly because of the time frame did not give us enough time to get all of our questions answered.

Bill Sturgeon
Bill Sturgeon
9 years ago

Tim: I have known Jerry Miller for many years! I have found him to be a man of integirty and for sure he is his “own man”!

Alfred Spielberg
Alfred Spielberg
9 years ago

I wanted to make a movie about a young lad growing up in a toxic ladened small city and experiencing major health problems due to industrial toxic waste.

Pittsfield seemed like the ideal location.

However, due to the complex political permitting process, the movie had to be scrapped.

Shakes His Head
Shakes His Head
9 years ago

There are some things that the Mayor needs to be able to do without City CLowncil voting on the actions. And the mayor should be able to pick his staff. There are dozens of non-union appointments that the Clowncil could not process efficiently. the due process is that the Mayor is elected. if the electorate is informed and does not like the mayor’s actions, then un-elect the mayor. Clowncil inefficiency and gridlock is not the solution.

Plain Jane
Plain Jane
9 years ago

Dan,

Wonering if you are planning on doing a column reporting on the Ebola problem spiraling out of control?

Dallas hospital has shut down their emergency room over one man who died there from Ebola:

http://www.shtfplan.com/headline-news/shutdown-a-single-ebola-patient-has-overwhelmed-the-system-dallas-hospital-forced-to-close-emergency-room_10132014

Not even the murder of a US President shut down a hospital’s emergency room in Dallas.

The nurse who contracted ebola from caring for the man – her boyfriend has now believed to have contracted the disease.

Doctor’s and nurses in Sierra Leone and Liberia have walked off the job because the risk’s are not worth it. Too many of them have already become infected.

The World Health Organization is reporting 10,000 new cases every week worldwide.

Also, the CDC is rumored to be preparing for up to 200 million deaths.

I would be interested in your opinion as to what’s going on here.

dusty
dusty
9 years ago

Ironically Dan Bianchi once fought hard to keep the Civic Authority from taking over the government. Now he is leading the charge to take all the power away from the people he is supposed to be working for.

By the way, what are the symptoms of Alzheimer?

Tom
Tom
Reply to  dusty
9 years ago

Alzheimer? More like a psychotic breakdown from reality.

joetaxpayer
joetaxpayer
9 years ago

I forget.What was the question?

Bill Sturgeon
Bill Sturgeon
9 years ago

The City’s Human Resource Director should be reviewing the credential of “ALL” applicants and ” validating their credentials and insure that they meet the MEQs. Once everything has been VALIDATED the HR Director should then recommend the top three (Explaining How They Received Their Rank). If the mayor decides to go select someone other than the individuals recommended by HR Director then the Council should be informed of this “FACT”.
If the mayor or the council wants to add another step in the process they can have the three names given to the appropriate committee for its review.

I know that it easy to blame the mayor and perhaps it is the right thing do at this point I don’t know. I agree he has got himself into a couple of real situations.

I think that this is fairly transparent. It’s just my opinion!

Bill Sturgeon
Bill Sturgeon
9 years ago

The City’s Human Resource Director should be reviewing the credential of “ALL” applicants and ” validating their credentials and insure that they meet the MEQs. Once everything has been VALIDATED the HR Director should then recommend the top three (Explaining How They Received Their Rank). If the mayor decides to go select someone other than the individuals recommended by HR Director then the Council should be informed of this “FACT”.
If the mayor or the council wants to add another step in the process they can have the three names given to the appropriate committee for its review.

I know that it easy to blame the mayor and perhaps it is the right thing do at this point I don’t know. I agree he has got himself into a couple of real situations.

I think that this is fairly transparent. It’s just my opinion!

Jonathan Melle
Jonathan Melle
9 years ago

If there was a high school textbook on municipal mismanagement, it would be called:
“City of Pittsfield, Massachusetts, USA”
Everything has gone badly for Pittsfield. Thousands of people have moved away. Thousands of jobs have been lost. Taxes are very high. Most people are low-income with social problems. Teen pregnancies double the statewide average. Pittsfield is the welfare capital on Massachusetts. Hundreds of school children choice out of Pittsfield’s public schools. Pittsfield has toxic waste cancer causing PCBs in its air, ground and water. Pittsfield politics is totally corrupt.

Jamie
Jamie
9 years ago

The move to 100 N st was done without council knowledge or involvement. The switch to BC-Bs was done without council knowledge or involvement. I talk to several councilors including my own and they found out first about it from DV and this website.

I would love to see DV run for mayor. He’s the only one I would trust at this point.

The appointing process begs for director of personel (HR John De Angleo) to speak up and out about it. Or is he too a wimp?

Bea Breef
Bea Breef
9 years ago

I agree, the Planet would make an excellent candidate!

Jonathan Melle
Jonathan Melle
9 years ago

NEWS ARTICLES:

“Anne Wojtkowski dies; engineer, educator and Pittsfield’s first woman mayor”
By Jim Therrien and Dick Lindsay, Berkshire Eagle Staff, 10/13/2014

PITTSFIELD — There were few glass ceilings in Berkshire County that Anne Everest Wojtkowski didn’t smash through.

Wojtkowski, who died Monday at 79, was the first woman to serve as mayor of Pittsfield (from 1988-92), championed equal pay for female college faculty, spearhead early childhood education, all while being dedicated to her family.

“My brother [Tom] and I were the most important to her,” said daughter, Dr. Marcella Bradway. “She gave up plenty of opportunities to go elsewhere.”

Instead, Wojtkowski chose her native Pittsfield to make her mark in public education and politics.

An engineer by trade — the first woman in her class at Boston University — the Pittsfield High School alum returned to the city in the 1960s from the Boston area with her husband, Thomas, and two young children. She would embark on a 35-year career as a professor of mathematics and engineering at Berkshire Community College, retiring from BCC in 2004.

Her first taste of a mayoral campaign was in 1981, when she ran for mayor and lost in the preliminary election. Six years later she successfully won the first of two consecutive two-year mayoral terms, breaking the gender barrier in the corner office at City Hall.

“Clearly she was a trailblazer for women in politics,” said state Rep. William “Smitty” Pignatelli, D-Lenox. “She not only cracked the glass ceiling, but she broke through it for other females to follow.”

Former state Sen. Andrea Nuciforo Jr., Wojtkowski’s nephew, said his aunt wasn’t about being first, but what’s best for her hometown.

“Anne got into public service for the same reason she got into education — she wanted to make a difference,” Nuciforo said. “She entered city government during a difficult time: GE was pulling out, PCBs was becoming a hot topic and the economy was in a downt[ur]n.”

At times, Wojtkowski butted heads with the City Council, only because she was adamant about getting things done, according to her daughter.

“It bothered her that she was misunderstood [as mayor,]” Bradway said. “She was contentious with the City Council, but if she had a point to make, she stuck with it.”

Wojtkowski’s re-election bid felt short in 1991, losing in the preliminary to her eventual successor, Edward Reilly.

The former city solicitor lauded Wojtkowski for being gracious in defeat and helping him transition into the mayor’s job before he was sworn in January of 1992.

“When I got elected, she gave me all the ins and outs of the office,” he said. “Even some of the people loyal to her stayed on during my first term.”

Reilly also praised Wojtkowski for being among active supporters of the efforts that led to a $16 million restoration of the Colonial Theatre a decade ago. She also helped the city buy and convert the old Capitol Theatre and movie house into the present-day senior center on North Street, which opened after Reilly became the city’s chief executive.

Wojtkowski’s mayoral career was sandwiched between her being a pioneer for the Pittsfield Public Schools and a trendsetter for higher education.

In 1967 at the age of 32, Wojtkowski won her first election as the city’s top vote-getter, winning a four-year term on the School Committee.

“There isn’t a good reason in the world why the Pittsfield school system can’t be one of the top systems, not only in the state but in the country,” she said in one of her first public statements after the election that year.

Wojtkowski went on to call for “an orderly reorganization of the [school] department along the lines recommended by [a consulting firm].”

Between the mid-1960s and early 1980s, she also served as the chairwoman of the School Building Needs Commission that oversaw a $9 million modernization project at Pittsfield High, completed in 1977.

Seven years earlier in 1970, she helped the city school system establish one of the nation’s first early childhood education programs, still in existence today.

“She was most proud of that,” Bradway said. “The kids were the most important to her; she was a very nurturing person.”

And persistent.

In 1983, she and another female professor initiated a lawsuit against BCC over an alleged lack of promotional and pay equity. The Massachusetts Teachers Association joined in the legal action and expanded it to include female educators and professionals at all state community colleges. Nine years later, the suit was settled for $10.6 million, considered the largest of its kind in Massachusetts and a springboard for the national movement for equal pay.

After taking a four-year hiatus from BCC to be mayor, Wojtkowski returned to the West Street campus, devoted to higher education and helping rebuild the local economy through the community college.

“I know we have engineers in Berkshire County and beyond who credit Anne with providing them with a top notch education,” said BCC President Ellen Kennedy. “They have successful careers because of Anne’s teaching.”

Wojtkowski also co-founded Berkshire Enterprises, an entrepreneurial program that has trained hundreds of Berkshirites to start their own businesses and create more than 1,100 jobs.

“We are a better community for her leadership and innovation,” Kennedy said.

In later years, Wojtkowski was an author, writing “Porcelain and Pottery Shoes,” and other books. She was a collector of souvenir china, past president of the Berkshire Historical Society and considered one of the best ever to sail on Pontoosuc Lake, The Eagle reported, sharing a love of sailing with her father, A. Walter Everest.

“She also made a killer chocolate cake,” Nuciforo said. “If people knew she was coming to an event bringing a cake, they would show up.”

—–

“Pittsfield’s First Female Mayor, Long-Time Educator Dies At 79”
By Jim Levulis – WAMC – October 14, 2014

The first female mayor of Pittsfield, Massachusetts died Monday at the age of 79. She’s remembered as having touched many lives through her work in education, public service and politics.

In 1988 Anne Everest Wojtkowski became the first woman to lead Pittsfield as mayor, an office she held for two terms until 1992. The Pittsfield native was an engineer by trade, becoming a professor of mathematics and engineering at Berkshire Community College for 35 years along with serving on the city’s school committee. Former State Senator Andrea Nuciforo remembers his aunt as a confident and committed person.

“She came into office as mayor at a time that was very difficult for the city, but she believed in the city, she believed in the promise of the people that live here and she was confident that she could make a difference,” said Nuciforo.

Wojtkowski led efforts to renovate the Colonial Theatre, convert the Capitol Theatre to the senior center on North Street and modernize Pittsfield High School.