‘FORBES’ LAYS IT OUT FOR TAXPAYERS ON DREARY PUBLIC PENSION SITUATION
BY DAN VALENTI
PLANET VALENTI NEWS AND COMMENTARY
(FORTRESS OF SOLITUDE, MONDAY DEC. 5, 2016) — Here’s some Christmas cheer from Forbes magazine, one you can be sure Pittsfield treasurer Matt “Kufflinks” Kerwood will conveniently miss. He’s another of the thousands who don’t read PLANET VALENTI!
From Forbes: “Massachusetts now has a $67 billion budget shortfall, making it the fourth-worst state in the union when it comes to “taxpayers’ burden,” according to an analysis by Truth in Accounting.
That’s an absolute ranking against America’s other 49 states. When you factor in the moribund and dead economies in Berkshire County and the city of Pittsfield respectively, it gets worse. Thanks to a generation of incessant public spending, tax hikes, declining population, and an influx of moochers (those on the dole who suck up services without contributing anything in return), Pittsfield ranks last among Commonwealth municipalities.
Papering Over the Hole in the Wall
Of course, with profligate public spenders of Kufflink’s ilk at the helm, the situation will worsen. To the city treasurer, this ponderous state of the economy represents a hole in the wall to wallpaper with triple talk that makes hazy former treasurer Dick Bordeau’s as clear as the Dick and Jane Reader.
One step Pittsfield must take if it wishes to avoid economic meltdown is pension reform. Current pension deals leave Pittsfield owing nearly half a billion dollars (yes, with a “b”) in post-employment liabilities. Those deals were negotiated “in good faith,” the apologists point out. True — if you leave out the prepositional phrase. There has been little “good faith” in city pacts, especially contracts signed by the Pittsfield School Department (PSD) on behalf of its 1,200 employees. “Good faith” would have given Mary Jane and Joe Kapanski a place at the negotiating table. With Kathy Yon, Kathy Amuso, John Krol, Peter Marchetti, and the rest of them clogging up the school committee and city council, the PSD negotiated with itself.
Pension reform can be accomplishged. Just as the current benefits were negotiated, so can they be renegotiated. It’s not a step THE PLANET would ever recommend lightly, but there is little light here. There is, however, a dark tunnel at the end of the little light there is. The solution:
- Elect politicians with the guts to petition Boston for home rule to renegotiating pensions.
- Sit down with the unions (especially teachers) and fashion realistic post-employment obligations.
- This will preserve retirement packages for public employees while giving taxpayers a much-needed break.
- Propse and pass municpial budgets that lower taxes for homeowners and businesses.
Pensions ‘Not Adequately Funded’
Further in the Forbes article, we find this:
State employees (including teachers) “have been promised $27.8 billion of pension benefits and $17 billion of retirees’ health care benefits, but the state has not adequately funded them. Unless these pension and retirees’ health care benefits are renegotiated, future taxpayers will be burdened with paying for these benefits without receiving any corresponding government services or benefits.”
The state may do as it wishes, but Pittsfield must act now. “Now” translates into “the municipal elections of 2017. Out with politics as usual.
Also from Forbes, we share this so people may be armed when we hear labor demanding $15 and hour for minimum wage:
Ed Rensi, the former president and CEO of McDonald’s USA, writes: “As the labor union-backed Fight for $15 begins yet another nationwide strike on November 29, I have a simple message for the protest organizers and the reporters covering them: I told you so. It brings me no joy to write these words. The push for a $15 starter wage has negatively impacted the career prospects of employees who were just getting started in the workforce while extinguishing the businesses that employed them. I wish it were not so. But it’s important to document these consequences, lest policymakers elsewhere decide that the $15 movement is worth embracing.”
——– 000 ——–
We better wake up economically before we blow the whole shooting match. That’s true for the country, state, and city. We can’t control national events. Statewide, we know Boston only cares about getting another set of Berkshire Representoids with no will except to do the will of their Masters. But locally, the people of Pittsfield could, if they could somehow unite determine their own destiny.
It begins in 2017.
———————————————————————
“One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.” — Milton Friedman
“OPEN THE WINDOW, AUNT MILLIE.”
LOVE FOR ALL.
The views expressed in the comment section or opinions published within the text other than those of PLANET VALENTI are not those of PLANET VALENTI or endorsed in any way by PLANET VALENTI; this website reserves the right to remove any comment that violates its Rules of Conduct, and it is not liable for the consequences of any posted comment as provided in Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act and PLANET VALENTI’s terms of service.
Need to worry how the City distributes it’s revenue. ovanta gets over half million for upgrades that should be part of thier Business, not at taxpayer expense.
Heh Heh wrote…. giving Beacon money for theatre seats, all the while our street lights are not on. What else does he have in that building? If apartments are in there, the better the funding for the Theatre projectsat no cost to him, enhances his other business he’ll get money from, seems fishy?
Pittsfield politics will never change or reform its municipal finances! It is the same thing every fiscal year! Around a 5% annual increase in the operational budget, plus a multi-million dollar capital budget, plus increasing debt costs, plus increasing opeb debt costs.
When was it any different?
It is as predictable as the Sun rising in the East and setting in the West each and everyday.
Dan Valenti picks on Matt Kerwood for maintaining the status quo. However, the lovely Linda Tyer was elected by the vested interests and she it keeping true to her promises of continued tax hikes.
The State Representatives and State Senators are in a “Catch 22” because they have to answer to the “Big Guys” or become outsiders. Adam Hinds, Tricia Farley-Bouvier, William “Smitty” Pignatelli, Paul Mark, and Gailanne Cariddi, will be more like “Bureaucrat$” than Legislator$, and they will be rewarded for “just following orders”.
The Bottom Line: Nothing will change!
– Jonathan Melle
Reply to Jonathan Melle: You are right and that’s very sad!
The only way to change it is to create
Resistance movement—PittsfieldResistance.com
We need to create tax-payer’s web site with an option to vote for each and every proposal and to say anything we want against city administration, Mayor and/ or Councilors.
We should be able to run Referendum campaigns on that web site, so lawyer should be involved to make it happen.
Talking and crying doens’t do much.
altrightlite.com?
Amuso Yon Taylor Tyer Behnke….Behnke gave herself a 30k raise to 120k and should be fired for that and added 3 new positions…she has a do nothing job and keeps her door closed…..Curtis 130k and has cost the city millions should be fired for incompetence.
The city schools are miserable places to work with incompetence in charge of everything.
but the money, perks and lots of time off makes it a little easier to take for some
Ask a teacher, they laugh themselves at all the time they get.
This is absolutely true and sad.
The sad thing is this blog where anyone can say anything they want and never be made to back it up with facts. We can all just run each other down or paint any or all people guilty and never have to own up to what we post.
Just having the right to say it, and then saying it, achieves at least the minimal level of owning up to the saying (or writing). That is especially true since our backstage software allows up to have the identity of everyone who comments.
Thomas Moore, you don’t have to make stuff up in Pittsfield the real stuff is more than interesting.
What teachers have you been talking to?
The list is rather long, and it spans many teacher friends throughout the districts in the berkshries. Let’s start with various SPED department teachers at both THS and PHS that simply won’t be named because when you see them at the bar this weekend, I don’t want them judged.
If you’d like me to throw a couple of shoddy “educators” and “counselors” under the bus, I’ll gladly do so. You can sort out the “facts” yourself
Wal-Mart Filler is basically blight. So, do you develope the eyesore for 12 plus million with a Big Box or do you continue to search for a business with good paying jobs to build,hurry, CoryDon’s Legacy is on the line.
Cory Don’s legacy was long long gone. He’s a do nothing, gets $70K a year, and spends his time in north county taking care of his real business. He doesn’t care at all about PEDA he cares only for his 70K pocket change.
I see Mike Bloomberg on the Kings Show. Mike is a relative to Mike Bloomberg the Multi Billionaire, about Thirty Six from what is written. young Bloomberg stays as his family does, in Pittsfield, why in the world wouldn’t you want a bright articulate man, who is willing to enter the fray in the political realm, who really isn’t an establishment candidate per say. He is sort of like a Trump, why not give him a chance before he does get polluted with the status quo,because the Vote’ didn’t elect him, simple as that!
Really?
Because he is a know it all brat. He thinks he has the answer to everything.
Talk to him sometime. He will make you feel like you are stupid.
If taking to Mike makes you think you are stupid then either you have a self-esteem issue or you really are stupid.
Check out the debris on the Public Health and Safety Meeting advocates selling another clinic, syringes, positive change is the reason for it???? Really????
And scientific Data………
http://www.berkshireeagle.com/stories/pittsfield-public-schools-district-makes-inclusivity-of-disabilities-home-situations-emotional-and,491211
I can’t wait to see how they like integrating the PHS ASP/EOS students. It’s going to do wonders for the mainstream students to see kids who daily swear, and threaten verbally/physically the teachers who have to babysit them. I’m sure a counselor/social worker will be sent in to read the paper while making sure their feelings aren’t hurt.
If your a friend of Amuso Yon Tyer Kroll White Marchetti…dont you as a friend ask them why theyou do such a lousy job.If your a friend don’t you think they are very irresponsible to the elderly.GO WALMART
Yeah go, please go. If it stays,they could put up a bill board..Wal- Mart Woodlawn Crossing at CoryDon Park.
Pay for Parking is joke, and is there a limit on hours, daily? Can the same cars park there day after day, it caters to the downtown workers, most older people Aren’t going to go through all the computer action.
Remember this little piece from Oct. 11 on THE PLANET?: AFTER CITY SCREWS UP PARKING YET AGAIN, YOUR BEST BET IS TO BUY A PARKED CAR
Downtown workers already have the parking system gamed. When I can park for free why would paying for it hourly help me?
Not all of us that work downtown have free parking FACT
Then you aren’t moving your car enough.
Its going to get uglier and soon. Perfect timing for your story Dan
http://www.msn.com/en-us/money/markets/a-pensions-time-bomb-spells-disaster-for-the-us-economy/ar-AAl8HZq?ocid=spartanntp
Just sayin
JOP P
Wow. A serendipitous event such as this coincidence only reinforces the bite of our column. This is a REAL problem Pittsfield better begins facing. The 2016 council and school committee is hopeless. 2017 must be the year for angry candidates ready to take back government FOR THE PEOPLE — snatch it right out of the hands of the special interests, who are the only ones making out in Pittsfield right now. All this as taxpayers, both homeowners and small business, are all but being ruined by the city’s insane spending. It doesn’t have to be this way. There is a way out, as you know, as THE PLANET knows.
Right, older people are way too dumb.
Y’mean move outta town?
You’re not kidding joe, good read. The first piece of the economic chaos will be physical,with the politicians and law enforcement. How are you going to keep order,when your City will be turned I to a socialist demography where only the taxpayer paid employees are making out. i
The Federal Government certainly isn’t going to bail out State -CIty Pension obligations.
Parking can only be a mess here in PIttsfield. That’s why we are called Palookaville.
I call it –village of Pittsfield:))
My cousin applied for a job with the City last year, but they gave it to someone from another state, far away. Why not hire local?
Really?
Maybe your mom wasn’t qualified. Did you think of that?
I’m sure you think she is because she is your mom and is qualified to do anything.
Really?
Oops, should have said cousin.
ha?
Pittsfield is a city that you must be anonymous when commenting.or pay.a severe price.The well paid will never open their mouth because their families would pay the price.Manny people are friends and neighbors of people who are ripping the city off but who wants to start WW3 with neighbor.Yon and Tyer need to feed this machine or be voted out.
Very well said School Committee.
And who’s going to report anything as Trump is attacking journalist and commedians.
Trump’s not attacking The Planet, however!
and why do you think the planet does not attack trump?
They attacked him first–this is self-defence:))
Excellent School Ommittee..
I was wondering about the couple million the city saved on snow removal and sanding and salting last year yet the taxes still went through the roof. How can you justify giving away tax breaks to millionaires and then tax the hell out of everyone else?
I guess I am just being an old nag about such things.
As good as yesterday’s take heh heh, hadn’t thought of this one, they’re were savings for sure.
Yes heh heh and School Committee have been coming up with some gems.. And a lot of Truth lies within.
Prediction, when Trump Officially becomes President, their will be more Chaos amongst not only our enemies, but all Americans against as well. The White Supremacist for Trump situation is a smoke screen, not a threat, but a media frenzy.
I agree H..I think you meant. There.”
No he really is supported by white supremacists.
There is a Reagan look a like right behind Trump in North Carolina thank you tour.. Got to be a Plant.
The gentleman over Trumps’s right shoulder, lol, he does H.
Trumpeteer says he’ll help our Vets, which is fine…. the main Theme of his Campaign was to put up a Wall, we will see,and jobs was number one, we will see. Donald, you will need seed money, you don’t GOT!
Trump’s ideology is nonsense. If North Korea lobs a Missile at someone, is he saying our Country won’t help defend such an action with no action and only protect our Country? Doesn’t make sense. We will have division among other Countries as well as in our own Country.
Our any of Trump’s properties in the Inner Cities, where he plans on investing over a Trillion Dollars.
Trumps safety of the American people first, that’s great, if Americans can stop harming other Ameicans, never happen, crime is inevitable, in any setting.
Domestic violence alone,is an epidemic,no class is immune from. Never mind drug and gang problems.
We have a new problem in America. Trump states,he is for law enforcement, yet, plainly dismisses the actions throughout the Country of needless killings, mostly against African Americans, this problem can only get worse when he takes office, he hasn’t addressed it during the campaign. Not good.He has the Senate and House to get a lot change, the question is, will this change be any good?
Trump is a modern day Wizard of Oz. His talking points are feel good, let’s see the action come next year.
Didn’t know Trump promised utopia. Yes, there will always be crime and senseless killings. Obama has divided this Country, like no other President in history. President Trump will get us going in the right direction. Obama will go down as the epic failure that he is. Cannot wait for January 20th, when he will finally be gone.
Your first line is a classic. Thanks, JOE T.
And thank God the heathen Hillary will not infest the place again
Trump promised all Americans that America will be great again.So they gave him their vote.He promised a lot.Trump hates real journalist. Trump loves white wash journalist.Trump want a free pass and Trump wont live in the White house
Yeah, Martha Raddatz is a “real journalist.” So is Dick Radatz.
And I forget which one was called the Monster
RIP, Monster. It will be awhile before people have trust in journalists again. The people have been misinformed to many times.