Article

GAZA: WHO WILL DARE QUESTION?

2.3 9 votes
Article Rating

BY DAN VALENTI

PLANET VALENTI NEWS AND COMMENTARY

(FORTRESS OF SOLITUDE, WEDNESDAY DEC. 20, 2013) — It’s time for the government of Israel and the Israel Defense Force (IDF) to stop playing victims.

Note THE PLANET says “government.” The decent people of the Jewish nation do not want the mindless killing. Neither do the majority of Palestinians. Human decency was the victim of Hamas on Oct. 7. The irrational mix of weaponized politics, power, religion and money (most from the United States) fed the brutal response. Now, Israel has lost control of its IDF, judged by the military’s continued atrocities.

———- ooo ———-

 IDF’s genocidal assault on innocent, defenseless Palestinian civilians, makes no sense on any level. Politically, diplomatically, strategically — there’s no way to triangulate a justification for the slaughter in Gaza.

From the Associated Press:

JERUSALEM — Israeli forces killed two women who were taking shelter at a church in the Gaza Strip on Saturday afternoon, Catholic authorities said.

The Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem, an ecclesiastical office for the Latin Catholics in the region, in a statement identified the victims — a mother and daughter — by their first names only and said they were “shot in cold blood.”

A sniper from the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) shot the women at the Holy Family Parish in Gaza, where the majority of Christian families in Gaza have taken refuge during the war, according to the patriarchate’s statement.

“Nahida and her daughter Samar were shot and killed as they walked to the Sister’s Convent,” the patriarchate said, referring to a building in the parish complex. “One was killed as she tried to carry the other to safety. Seven more people were shot and wounded as they tried to protect others inside the church compound. No warning was given, no notification was provided. They were shot in cold blood inside the premises of the Parish, where there are no belligerents.”

The IDF did not immediately respond to a request for comment, and The Washington Post could not immediately verify the details of the patriarchate’s report.

Of course the IDF did not respond. How does one justify cold-blooded murder of three escaped Israeli hostages, who were waving white flags and begging, in Hebrew, for help?

———- ooo ———-

Israel has now killed 18,000 Palestinians, most of them innocent civilians. 200,000 have been injured, and 90% of the 2.3 million Gaza population have been uprooted from their homes.

Let this sink in. Picture yourself in that situation.

From Bloomberg:

The United Nations General Assembly voted overwhelmingly to demand a cease-fire in the Gaza Strip, underscoring a sharp shift in sentiment that’s left Israel and the US increasingly isolated over the military campaign to destroy Hamas.

The General Assembly adopted the non-binding resolution by a vote of 153 to 10, with 23 nations abstaining. The Czech Republic and Austria were the only two European Union nations that voted against the resolution. The resolution demanded an immediate humanitarian cease-fire and an immediate release of all hostages.

Last week, the US vetoed a Security Council resolution that would have called for a cease-fire to the war, which began after Hamas fighters attacked Israel on Oct. 7, killed some 1,200 people and took 240 more hostage. Israeli forces responded with a punishing military campaign that the Hamas-run Health Ministry says has killed some 18,000 people. The US doesn’t have veto power in the larger General Assembly.

———- ooo ———-

And briefly, just today, a couple headlines from Reuters (with hot links):

  • Israel kept pounding the shattered Gaza Strip while Yemen’s pro-Palestinian Houthi movement vowed to defy a US-led naval mission and keep hitting Israeli targets in the Red Sea.
  • A number of container ships are anchored in the Red Sea and others have turned off tracking systems as traders adjust routes and prices in response to maritime attacks by Yemen’s Iran-aligned Houthis.

As the worldwide calls for ceasefire continue, Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu has tripled down, vowing to continue the butchery. THE PLANET rejects his justifications.

A child will cry.

A mother will beg for mercy.

An old man will hold out his hand for aid.

A young man will be starving.

The IDF will bury them all under concrete and rubble.

Do you dare question it?

——————————————————————–

Circumstance can be justified by context, but context, itself, is only the effect of a previous cause” — Sir Donald Turpentine, Knight of the Bath.

“OPEN THE WINDOW, AUNT MILLIE.”

LOVE TO ALL.

Copyright (c) 2023 By Dan Valenti, PLANET VALENTI and EUROPOLIS MANAGEMENT. All rights reserved. The views and opinions expressed in the comment section or in the text other than those of PLANET VALENTI are not necessarily endorsed by the operators of this website. PLANET VALENTI assumes no responsibility for such views and opinions, and it reserves the right to remove or edit any comment, including but not limited to those that violate the website’s Rules of Conduct and its editorial policies. Those who leave comments own all the responsibilities that are or can be attached to those comments, be they rhetorical, semantic, or legal. Such commentators remain solely responsible for what they post and shall be and remain solely accountable for their words. PLANET VALENTI shall not be held responsible for the consequences that may result from any posted comment or outside opinion or commentary as provided in, but not limited to, Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act and this website’s terms of service. We serve as a marketplace of ideas, without prejudice and available to all. All users of this site — including readers, commentators, contributors, or anyone else — hereby agree to these conditions by virtue of this notice and their use of/participation in this site. When PLANET VALENTI ends with the words “The Usual Disclaimer,” that phrase shall be understood to refer to the full text of this disclaimer.

2.3 9 votes
Article Rating
98 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
ShirleyKnutz
ShirleyKnutz
4 months ago

Since the creation of the state of Israel, the Palestinians and their neighbors have continually attempted to overthrow the state and take them over. Picture you grew up in a state where bombs rained down continually throughout your life, you never had the sense of safety. How would you respond 80 years later when you witnessed a barbaric murder spree at a gala? Then you go into the neighboring country who have taken your citizens hostage while raping them and beating them up. You notice they blend in with the crowds, You also see tunnels built under the city. You can’t tell me the citizens of this area didn’t know what their government was doing, yet they never let the Israeli government know so they could of handled it. I don’t condone what is happening in the middle east but I am living in a rather safe place so I don’t believe anyone over here can make a comment/ As for the UN I say send in the UN police led by the Chinese and Russian troops and sprinkle in some other choice countries, I say good luck it’s been an atrocious place to live for thousands of years and I do not see it improving.

Joetaxpayer
Joetaxpayer
4 months ago

Gaza, Ukraine, even Hunter, all to distract us from the destruction of our Country. Invasion of the border, political prisoners, losing our right to vote for who we want. Democracy in the US is under attack.

Markus Aurelius
Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

I read that and then I think to posts from Kindergarden, JM, Snark, and TSC, who chose China Joe Xiden and our current day situation, both domestically and abroad, because mean tweets and locker-room guy talk, offended them or didn’t bring “honesty and honor” to other world leaders.

In Kindergarden’s own words, he stated Trump didn’t bring “honesty and honor” to the world stage. He offers nothing to back this claim up though.

I disagree: no wars, affordable groceries, gas, home loans, low inflation, low interest rates, a secure border, fentanyl not ravaging our country, free speech, gay porn and drag shows out of elementary school aged children’s view, that certainly fits the bill for “honesty and honor,” in my book.

Kindergarden
Kindergarden
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

Markus, I’m quite sure there’s nothing I could say that would make you feel closer to the way I feel about it. But that’s ok, because what you and your compadres say don’t really change my basic positions on these issues, even if what you say does increase my level of empathy for you guys.

But, I’ll say it anyway. Leaders in Europe and the Middle East have no respect for the T-man because his words are disingenuous and self-serving. Putin would love to have him back in power because he supports Putin and is easy for Putin to manipulate. Finland has joined NATO with Biden’s support while Trump would defund it and close it down. Trump would pull back from the world stage with his isolationist policies leaving a power vacuum happily filled by Putin and Xi Jinping. Our allies cannot rely on Trump because he doesn’t follow standard state department policy and is therefore unpredictable.

Affordable groceries, gas, home loans, low inflation and low interest rates are pre-Covid phenomena that have zero to do with Trump.

No wars, of course, because Trump caves and gives the other side what it wants.

Trump wouldn’t be able to solve the border, fentanyl and immigration problems, and his enacting government control of drag shows and women’s freedom is where you and I profoundly disagree.

I know you see these arguments as offering nothing to back the claim that Trump didn’t bring “honesty and honor” to the world stage. What Trump does bring is hope to people like you, Pat, etc. contributors to this board – hope that things will be better with him in charge. That is the function of Dan’s blogsite – to provide a forum for the disaffected – a function that it fulfills nicely.

Markus Aurelius
Markus Aurelius
Reply to  Kindergarden
4 months ago

Xi stated he never trusted Trump, because he (Xi) could not predict Trump’s next move.

Translation for you simpletons: Trump’s not bought and paid for like the rest of our “leaders” are and we (China) don’t own and control him.

But sure K, keep telling yourself Trump was easily manipulated by other world leaders.

If you think drag shows should be shown to elementary aged children, you are a pedophile. Pure and simple. That’s was NEVER allowed in your and/or my day and it should stay that way.

Do the words adult entertainment mean anything to you? Or is it just far left-leaning agenda driven?

Kindergarden
Kindergarden
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

Markus, calling me a simpleton? You know shit.

Xi Jinping has no respect for Trump, and neither does Putin.

Trump is bought and paid for by Putin, and is susceptible to Putin’s flattery.

I don’t think drag shows should be shown to elementary school children.

Adult entertainment is for adults, pure & simple.

Markus Aurelius
Markus Aurelius
Reply to  Kindergarden
4 months ago

I know you have a PhD degree Kindergarden. May I suggest you brush up on reading comprehension.

My fourth paragraph, which addresses drag shows, starts with the word “If.” I did not call you a pedo. I said, “If you think…” Huge difference my friend.

Xi has “no respect for Trump,” according to you. How do you explain this?

Xi told Biden he plans to take Taiwan — peacefully if possible (nypost.com)

Don’t quite remember Xi telling Trump he had plans to “take Taiwan,” during Trump’s presidency. Our military is stretched then and weak, what an opportunity for Xi. Not to mention our current “leaders” are all bought and paid for by China.

Reread my third paragraph above and keep repeating it to yourself K. Maybe one day you might actually believe the BS you try and pass off to us. We certainly don’t.

Kindergarden
Kindergarden
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

I never said you called me a pedo. You’re the one who needs to reread.

I have worked with Chinese intel since before you could ride a bicycle. I have lived in Taiwan and speak the local S. Min dialect. Xi is not about to talk Taiwan politics seriously with a dummy loser like Trump. Trump understands about as much about the PRC-Taiwan military situation as he does about elementary particles in quantum physics.

I will match my reading comprehension skills up against yours any day.

Markus Aurelius
Markus Aurelius
Reply to  Kindergarden
4 months ago

Didn’t you try to tell me once you were on the front lines in VM? Or am I confusing you with someone else?

I know if you did all that you certainly were not.

Use your reading comprehension skills and tell me two things China Joe Xiden has done for the average American.

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

He never claimed to be in the Bush. He said Intelligence. Consistent with his remarks about being involved later in Chin Intel.

I have all encompassing differences with K, but I don’t see dishonesty in him.

Last edited 4 months ago by Charles Kronick
Kindergarden
Kindergarden
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

I’ve already done that a few times for you, which you forget, and I’m not going to do it again.

I told you and everyone that I am indeed a VN combat vet.

Gobsig
Gobsig
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

He watches too much View and PMSNBC.

Tt2
Tt2
Reply to  Kindergarden
4 months ago

You are part of the problem. Bleeding heart cry babies like you have been fed this crap for years. This is why we are weak as a country, weak as a people. You probably think it is also ok to teach young kids about trannies and I dont mean a car part.

Kindergarden
Kindergarden
Reply to  Tt2
4 months ago

Tt2, you are part of the problem as well.

Mad Trapper
Mad Trapper
Reply to  Tt2
4 months ago

In my younger days, blowing a tranny meant you had car problems…

Tt2
Tt2
Reply to  Kindergarden
4 months ago

Trump didnt give to any one the treats if power, tarrifs said enough.

Kindergarden
Kindergarden
Reply to  Tt2
4 months ago

Tariffs cost YOU.

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  Kindergarden
4 months ago

It’s hard to measure cost alone at the check out line though. The impact of tariffing the goods of competitors and enemies seeks to balance trade and increase domestic wealth: manufacturing jobs and domestic insulation against foreign generated chaos.

Our trade deals with Mexico and Canada were a sell out of domestic labor and agriculture. They shipped us their goods, we shipped them our factories. The Canadian ripoff was largely in unfair agri export regulation. We had to buy their stuff, they tariffed us in compensation. (It’s what the Ukrainians are doing now to Poland. Dumping.)

Only because we have become IMPORT RELIANT. Tariffs are used to protect domestic production. The fact that they are distinctly felt is a reflection of the loss of wealth due to trade imbalance that had been cultivated since the 1980’s.

The irrational and draconian response to COVID, despite their evils, revealed the visual truth of our failed trade policy. The queue of ships from Europe and Asia, miles out into the oceans with each ship bearing the fruits of wasted energy (carbon dioxide) of junk, tropical insects looking for fresh habitats, and things of value that had once bore “MADE IN USA” which meant just that all waiting to be unloaded in our ports.

I read that one ship alone is the equivalent of an Empire State building. Not sure I believe it, but the scale is likely accurate.

Last edited 4 months ago by Charles Kronick
Acute Angina
Acute Angina
Reply to  Kindergarden
4 months ago

You should seek help for your delusions.

Kindergarden
Kindergarden
Reply to  Acute Angina
4 months ago

I’m fine, thanks.

The school committee
The school committee
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

You now believe exactly what Marge Taylor Green believes.Qanon and FOX arereally great tools of Putin.

Acute Angina
Acute Angina
Reply to  The school committee
4 months ago

Thanks for TY he information

Markus Aurelius
Markus Aurelius
Reply to  The school committee
4 months ago

TSC, the only tool is you.

How do you know so much about Putin, but can’t name me a couple of things China Joe Xiden has done to help the average American taxpayer?

snark shark
snark shark
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

I could try to block out of my mind the horrors of what is going on in GAZA if it were Israel taking care of its OWN business. But, as an American I am not comfortable with my country being a part of it.
If any other country in the world was doing this the U.S. world police would be screaming Human Rights violation and genocide at the top of their lungs.
But one must understand that, going forward this type of warfare is now acceptable. Because America says so. America aided and abetted it. And when the backlash comes to America, as it certainly will, don’t cry in your soup and ask why they would come after us.

p.s. And right now the only reason I choose Biden is…… BECAUSE HE IS NOT TRUMP!!! If I see a better democrat OR republican running in 2024 I will vote for them. I am not at all party specific. I just want someone who is not a total and bona-fide nutcase wack job poison pill for all society.

Joetaxpayer
Joetaxpayer
Reply to  snark shark
4 months ago

That’s funny, because the number one reason I want President Trump to win is to get you and TSC to jump off a bridge.

Kindergarden
Kindergarden
Reply to  Joetaxpayer
4 months ago

The only thing you need to know about Trump is that when he lost the popular and electoral vote, he tried to subvert the democratic process – he tried to stop the counting of electoral votes to stay in power.

That’s all you need to know about Donald Trump.

Markus Aurelius
Markus Aurelius
Reply to  snark shark
4 months ago

And who armed HAMAS financially with US taxpayer money and with military grade weapons left behind in Afghanistan?

Sure wasn’t Trump.

I don’t blame the IDF. They thought it was fun and games live streaming while they murdered innocent Israeli’s. You reap what you sow.

And ask yourself why bordering countries didn’t want Palestinians citizens in their countries?

No wars under Trump.

If we go to war under Xiden’s watch, any of you guys volunteering? And if your told old, how about your kids? Will you talk them into singing up for a war in the ME?

snark shark
snark shark
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

Yup, just as I thought. My main point sailed far over your heads. The one thing all Trump disciples seem to be afflicted with is tunnel vision. They cannot think outside the box Trump has lured them into. The constant barrage of disinformation that is sent to them on their computers and mail takes over their brains. I have a family member who gets all this stuff. He repeats it. He resends it to others as instructed. And as ridiculous and as easily refutable as most of that crap is, he marches forward, blinded by the cult, believing the unbelievable.

There is very little different between Jimmy Jones and Trump and you people know that if Trump told you to walk out in front of a bus that you would do it without hesitation. And that is just sad and there is apparently no treatment for it.

But that aside, good luck and Merry Christmas to you and your family.

Tt2
Tt2
Reply to  snark shark
4 months ago

Biden what are you smoking? As for that area and people it has been a mess for over 100 years and I most of those people are taught to hate the USA and other countries that support freedom. They voted these animales into power and are no better then they are.

Jon Melle
Jon Melle
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

Why do you have to put my initials on your anti-Biden blog post? I want 2 new nominees for president in 2024. I hope that all terrorists groups will be killed so that they cannot kill innocent people and Peoples. The U.S. Constitution should have that in writing. Hamas is EVIL! I’m saddened that around 20,000 innocent people and Peoples have been killed so far since October 7th, 2023. By the way, my VOTE on January 23rd, 2024, in the NH Primary won’t count in the rules of the Democratic Party. I still get to VOTE, but it will mean nothing.

Markus Aurelius
Markus Aurelius
Reply to  Jon Melle
4 months ago

I added you JM, because you have posted on here that you “will never vote for Trump, because of his millionaire playboy ways.”

So, because a rich man enjoyed the company of many women, perfectly legal mind you, you’ll vote for China Joe Xiden and his current destruction of our country? Does that make sense to you? It certainly doesn’t to me.

Hopefully a couple of thousand illegals can make their way into your NH enclave and you can “enjoy” the diversity your party is ILLEGALLY heaping on the rest of the country.

That’s why you were added to the list.

Jonathan A. Melle
Jonathan A. Melle
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
4 months ago

I wish that: BOTH the over 50-year career politician in the SWAMP and the ultimate MORAL HYPOCRITE would retire from national politics. If the Democrats nominate Biden, then they are going back to the dreaded 1970’s era of big spending and big government with high U.S. inflation and low GDP growth. If the Republican nominate Trump, then they are going back to the dreaded 1920’s era of institutional racism (that Adolf Hitler wrote favorably about in his 100-year-old Nazi books) and extreme economic inequality with growth in the nation’s huge underclass and the top 1 percent of wealthy U.S. households.

Why do the Democrats want to take us back 50 years? Why do the Republicans want to take us back 100 years? These dates in history are ugly bygone eras that belong in the trash bin of U.S. history. We need to live in the current realities of the 21st Century with new candidates for U.S. President who will deliver progress for all of the American People!

What is the definition of INSANITY? The American People supporting either Joe Biden or Donald Trump for U.S. President because we would be doing the same thing over and over again while expecting different results.

It Can’t Bea
It Can’t Bea
4 months ago

Just another Gaza Friday da da da,wish it Monday da da da. Give us the report card!,

It Can’t Bea
It Can’t Bea
Reply to  It Can’t Bea
4 months ago

Budget Report Card….
Kronick A+
FUDD F
Kavey C-
Conant F
Kalinowsky B
Disco Dina F
Persip .. absentee
White D
Marchetti D-
Warren C
Maffuccio F

Tyer F

Earl Parsnip
Earl Parsnip
Reply to  It Can’t Bea
4 months ago

For not being there he should get an A.

Ozias Vincelette
Ozias Vincelette
Reply to  It Can’t Bea
4 months ago

A tough marker.

Tax&Spend
Tax&Spend
Reply to  It Can’t Bea
4 months ago

You want the mayoral report card?

Sonny
Sonny
4 months ago

Your source for the number of deaths is the Gaza Health Ministry, must be true. I don’t think any Americans especially incompetent leaders and brain washing educators should tell Israel what their response should be to a massacre of their citizens. There were horrific and animalistic acts committed by Hamas savages. There are recent polls that show 3/4 of Palestinians approve of the attack and Hamas activities since. Nobody wants to see innocent people harmed during a war. As everybody knows Hamas doesn’t follow that belief. A ceasefire does nothing. Can Hamas be eradicated? Probably not. Why has this inept administration released a possible 10 billion $$ for Iran. Most terror runs thru Iran. That is where people who want to tell Israel how to run their Country should put their energy. Biden and the Puppeteers are funding both sides of this Conflict. Why has this Country and the whole globe become Anti Semitic + Pro Hamas to a Nation the size of New Jersey? That is the real question and the answer can be seen in the state of the World.

snark shark
snark shark
Reply to  Sonny
4 months ago

Interesting. “Recent polls show 3/4 of Palestinians approve of the attack and Hamas activities since.”

I am trying to picture, in the middle of non stop bombing and obliteration and genocide, a guy going around interviewing people about how they feel about this or anything else. Starving, bloodied, disease ridden, homeless people are stopping to respond to a poll taker? Really? Do ya think maybe Israel just made that shit up perhaps?

Yah they did!

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
4 months ago

Media speaks of Hamas killing 1200 Israelis focus on a concert. They whitewash the murder.

The killers invaded homes, (it’s hard to write this, and what follows shall sear your mind.)

They placed infants in ovens before their parents eyes.

It is a sin that demands fatal consequences for those who make their company of such creatures. The terrorists are not of man, and death is their wish and future.

Phtnetl
Phtnetl
Reply to  Charles Kronick
4 months ago

Moses says this kind of conduct results in Certain death.

Phtnetl
Phtnetl
Reply to  danvalenti
4 months ago

Moses Malone.

Brad Pittsfield
Brad Pittsfield
Reply to  danvalenti
4 months ago

Moses Horwitz

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  Phtnetl
4 months ago

Chuckle then Phen.

The Japanese chuckled when they hid their military plants at Hiroshima, and the Germans laughed when they hid their military factories beneath the streets of Dresden. Both the IMperial Japanese and the Germans busily annihilated civilians in their homes for psychological pressure alone.

In war, the purpose is to win and defeat evil men: where the evil goes, goes you.

Last edited 4 months ago by Charles Kronick
H.L. Mencken
H.L. Mencken
Reply to  Charles Kronick
4 months ago

Pay your taxes, Chucky.

Tt2
Tt2
Reply to  Charles Kronick
4 months ago

Agree Sir Charles that whole area has been a hostile mess for every and will continue to be until they are put down.

Gobsig
Gobsig
Reply to  Charles Kronick
4 months ago

Help them get their 27 virgins

The school committee
The school committee
4 months ago

30 million for a new Stadium built inside a swamp.This is the absolute worst location you could pick for a brand new Stadium for Bill Murry and DaveVeecks Suns college summer team.Next the will be pro pickleball we built.

Tax&Spend
Tax&Spend
Reply to  The school committee
4 months ago

Bill Murray would’ve been a good mayor. Everything the guy did, he did 110 percent.

U.R. Cuckoo
U.R. Cuckoo
4 months ago

If Hamas surrenders the killing stops

Phtnetl
Phtnetl
Reply to  U.R. Cuckoo
4 months ago

The killing of children.

Tt2
Tt2
Reply to  Phtnetl
4 months ago

Dont believe anything that comes out of their mouths. All liars, cheats, theives, rapists, murders

Tt2
Tt2
Reply to  U.R. Cuckoo
4 months ago

Kill em all lot Allah sort them out

Mad Trapper
Mad Trapper
4 months ago

I don’t give a rat’s arse what happens in Middle East or Ukraine.

The DC Swamp crooks need to: seal the border, stop giving these criminals benefits, and deport the 10+ MILLION Traitor Joe has let in already.

In Da Know
In Da Know
Reply to  Mad Trapper
4 months ago

I bet you beat you beat your dog Rube

Mad Trapper
Mad Trapper
Reply to  In Da Know
4 months ago

My dog isn’t named Ruby!

Pat
Pat
4 months ago

The Gaza strip will be a much better place to live when it’s not ruled by terrorists. The Palestinians don’t know what it’s like to be free of terrorism ruling their country. Taking the money meant for the people of Gaza and using it to build tunnels to kill their enemies isn’t the way to rule over the people. Israel is helping the people of Gaza in the long run by freeing them from the tyrannical rule of Hamas.

Phtnetl
Phtnetl
Reply to  Pat
4 months ago

B So the owner of Meth. Bar was at the license board again Overcrowding,no doorman and cover charge removed. She claims she was overwhelmed? Where’s the help? She has been previously before the board for this allegation. Police did a good job but the Fire Department was absent at the meeting prompting the Board Chairman to state it can’t be that important because they didn’t show? Amuso stated you can dance on the bar now just not during Covid?

Powell was asked his opinion,and well,he was talking about sardines in a can. They all voted no nothing and hope business does well. This is what you’ve got now in your City. I believe it’s called gobsig.

A note to other business owners. If your ever brought before their board for overcrowding refer to this past decision. Just say you’ll do better.

Empty Set
Empty Set
Reply to  Phtnetl
4 months ago

Perhaps she would benefit from another Covid funding from her friends at city hall. Or perhaps some crowd funding like the Thistle folk. Either way it seems like the appropriate folk from the collective are washing each others backs and life will go on.

But if that octogenarian on Boylston street does not shovel the snow off her walk within 24 hours she will get a nice deduction from her social security check and be put on a watch list.

ShirleyKnutz
ShirleyKnutz
Reply to  Phtnetl
4 months ago

Tax and Spend are still very active in the city to keep the GOBSIGS happy$$. Just don’t complain about your taxes!! I often wonder what would happen if all taxpayers would just stop paying their taxes because of receiving no services for their hard earned $$

Longyear V
Longyear V
Reply to  Phtnetl
4 months ago

I believe she has multiple hearings and suspensions including an overcrowding suspension.This was a very serious violation. The board and Fire Department dropped the ball. Board should resign.

We pay our officers to uphold the law,they do there job and it’s pretty embarrassing that she would recieve a minimum of suspension. The quote by the chairman was quite disturbing when he mentioned the fire department wasn’t here so it could’ve been that big a deal?

Empty Set
Empty Set
Reply to  Longyear V
4 months ago

True dat. It was a particularly ignorant comment but not really when you consider the source. But it does set a precedent for the next violator who is brought forward. And that is assuming the police even bother the next time rules are being broken.

Gobsig
Gobsig
4 months ago
Mr. Worldwide
Mr. Worldwide
4 months ago

Maybe taxes wouldn’t go up so much if people like Ward 1 Councilor paid their fair share of taxes. The guy is a deadbeat and shouldn’t be representing the citizens of Ward 1.

He said he isn’t the beneficiary of the trusts, that his mother is. The question is, does he pay his rent to her? If he does, she should be able to pay the taxes.

He and his sister are the Trustees of the two trusts. As the Trustees it is their responsibility to pay the bills.

Either way, the guy is a dead beat!

Longyear V
Longyear V
Reply to  Mr. Worldwide
4 months ago

Apparently he’s not paying his dental plan either.

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  Mr. Worldwide
4 months ago

Do deadbeats pay their bills?

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  Mr. Worldwide
4 months ago

I wasn’t in the room with K when he spoke to Meg, so I can’t tell what he said. Maybe he said nothing at all.

Last edited 4 months ago by Charles Kronick
ShirleyKnutz
ShirleyKnutz
4 months ago

Just read an article on the “T” in Boston. I guess they want $4 Billion from the state so they can complete the repairs they need and pay for the running of the system. Let’s think about this why should Pitts pay for the “T”??? Also the government is pushing a train to run the length of the state….do you think that won’t cost us money that we don’t have??? The government is out of control (or being controlled by China not sure which). Hopefully people will start writing their reps to tell them to stop this nonsense. I would rather send my money to Texas to help with the human crisis at t he border that the czar Kamala has ignored with Biden’s blessing

Mr. Worldwide
Mr. Worldwide
4 months ago

Here is another thought.

Didn’t these same deadbeat councilor’s argue that the City should offset it’s rent payments to Petricca for the bus lease against the taxes he owes for the property he owns on Merrill Road? And didn’t they say that the City shouldn’t do business with the deadbeat?

Yet they continue to collect their salary and health insurance from the City as City Councilors. Shouldn’t we withhold their salary and health insurance against the taxes they owe? Or should their be a rule, if you owe, you can’t be an elected official?

I wish the citizens knew of Kenny’s delinquency before the election. Maybe someone would have run against him. Maybe someone will start a recall petition against the deadbeat.

Gobsig
Gobsig
Reply to  Mr. Worldwide
4 months ago

Can I suggest that you buy a dictionary, Mr. Their?

Lenny
Lenny
Reply to  Mr. Worldwide
4 months ago

I agree. Kenny’s up to his eyeballs in unpaid taxes.

Herb Pease
Herb Pease
Reply to  Lenny
4 months ago

Because Tyer pisses money away

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  Lenny
4 months ago

Unlikely. Article states that he has no tax debt. Big deal?

Brad Pittsfield
Brad Pittsfield
Reply to  Mr. Worldwide
4 months ago

Why are you always so mean. Do you enjoy being evil?

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  Brad Pittsfield
4 months ago

The soul of the City.

The downtown umbrella guy
The downtown umbrella guy
4 months ago

Watch out local businesses, it’s Pittsfield tonight has started it’s grift back up. Promising to be non political.our local leech wanting small business money for a poorly edited video on a rinky-dink Facebook page.

U.R. Cuckoo
U.R. Cuckoo
Reply to  The downtown umbrella guy
4 months ago

Maybe, you could start a top notch Facebook page and show us how it’s done.

Umbrella guy
Umbrella guy
Reply to  U.R. Cuckoo
4 months ago

Way to out yourself Mike

Last edited 4 months ago by Umbrella guy
Merry & Bright
Merry & Bright
4 months ago

Amazing that the Eagle blocks us from reading articles on their Facebook yet there is no block in place for the latest dirt story about the four City Councilors that are late on paying their taxes. What a dirt paper, who fed you this story? Noticed also that the first person to respond with an angry face emoji towards these councilors was no other than Mayor Dirty Barry. Hope this makes you feel like a man Barry! It was alright for you and your wife’s crap Administration to allow both the Arace and Petricca families to owe the city thousands of dollars for years in taxes, no public notification about that. Guess it depends on who “your friends are”, right Barry and LInda.

To the owners of the Berkshire Eagle, there are many issues in this failing city you could write about instead of digging into people’s personal finances. Your paper harassed John Krol, now these four councilors. How are the Eagle’s finances? Why is it you keep raising prices on a lousy paper that gets smaller by the day? Hope Karma works against you this new year.

Cat Tastrophee
Cat Tastrophee
Reply to  Merry & Bright
4 months ago

Is this the big story coming out of city hall that was rumored? I thought it was for a very questionable Covid distribution. Someone ought to investigate the mayors hiring at b c c? There were no other candidates with more quakifications? No people of color or minorities?

Pat
Pat
Reply to  Merry & Bright
4 months ago

No mention by the Eagle of the years of unpaid taxes of Hunter Biden when he was making millions. That’s okay because he is politically useful to the far left.

TellitLikeitIs
TellitLikeitIs
Reply to  Merry & Bright
4 months ago

Dummy up. There are elected officials, not private citizens. The Eagle has a responseabiliy to report it, and if only Danno could have scooped it first, he would have.

Empty Set
Empty Set
4 months ago

The local paper has a story about certain city councilors who owe back taxes. As it happens they all voted against the latest tax increases. Wondering if the message is that if you do not vote as you are told to by the administration the mayor will sic her media dog on you and try to embarrass you into compliance in the future.

Are there other people in the city that owe even more? Like business owners or some of the more well to do connected folk that they are planning on writing about? Can anyone think of any big shots that are getting tax breaks or had their taxes waved?

Dan, does this look like a shot over the bow to any councilor who might think about voting their own mind and going against the administrations dictate? Was this meant to intimidate any new councilor as to what is and what is not expected of them?
Will Marchetti now be able to get that coveted 11-0 vote every time?

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  Empty Set
4 months ago

The story, as always, is not about the report which is dull, but that which is unreported: who supplied the tip and for what end?

#1 is guessable to anyone on the clerk’s mail list. #2 is obvious: it’s a warning to the public not to run without permission, and it’s to discipline the councilor from Ward 1. He paid the bill and now it’s not a story.

I feel bad for the one who explained his hardship. I hope he makes it.

Last edited 4 months ago by Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  Empty Set
4 months ago

It’s a warning directed at you, ES. The councilors are irrelevant. Always have been.

Joetaxpayer
Joetaxpayer
Reply to  Empty Set
4 months ago

No . He will get the votes he needs to do whatever he wants. That’s just the way it works in Pittsfield. I will tell you as an owner of a Commercial building in Pittsfield, the only people making money is the City and their connected friends. Unfortunately I’m not in that group, breaking even. My last property in Pittsfield, steering everyone away from Pittsfield. Second highest commercial tax rate in the State, plus water and sewer and the second highest electric rate in the continental US. Stay away.

Cat Tastrophee
Cat Tastrophee
Reply to  Empty Set
4 months ago

He already had 11.

Jon Melle
Jon Melle
4 months ago

The Dirty Bird (Berkshire Eagle) did the dirty deeds done dirt cheap again by publishing 4 City Councilors’ arrears with the City of Pittsfield.

Joetaxpayer
Joetaxpayer
4 months ago

Onto a lighter note. Is Pittsfield Ma. in the running for the smallest X-Mass tree lighting in the Country. Pretty sure there hasn’t been a public display under 9 feet. At least we have that to hang our hat on. Merry Christmas to all, even the Moonbats.

John Dutton
John Dutton
4 months ago

The Berkshire Eagle is just a absolute complete joke. Heather Bellow among others have never set foot in a journalism class start with that but hey they are investigative journalist. These stories have become their bread and butter. Lazy journalists who relies on others for stories to write including the Planet.

These dopey lazy stories meant to discredit political enemies continue. The Berkshire Eagle is and has been a Gotcha newspaper for some time. Kevin who me Moran and Fred i can barely function Rutberg lead this rag tag hanging by a nose hair operation. It Goes lock and step with the rest of this city.

Last edited 4 months ago by John Dutton
Cat Tastrophee
Cat Tastrophee
Reply to  John Dutton
4 months ago

Moran and Rootburg is an amateur compared to Valenti..

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
Reply to  John Dutton
4 months ago

Scoop by Evelyn Waugh. That’s them there.

Charles Kronick
Charles Kronick
4 months ago

Fair Share Amendment (according to Berkshire Eagle). $1,000,000,000 raised in taxes. Berkshire County combined gets $4,580,000 of the pie. That amounts to 0.5% share.

Fair Share indeed.