Article

OPEN MIND, DIALOGUE: THE REMEDY FOR RHETORICAL IGNORANCE AND CANCEL CULTURE

5 2 votes
Article Rating

BY DAN VALENTI

PLANET VALENTI NEWS AND COMMENTARY

(FORTRESS OF SOLITUDE WEDNESDAY SEPT.  23, 2025) — Last week, THE PLANET had the pleasure of delivering an author talk in the guise of alter-ego, writer Dan Valenti. We changed in a nearby phone booth, spoke for an hour, took questions, then sold and signed books. We’ve been doing this since late spring in various cities and locations.

The audience included a former city office holder who happens to be on the November ballot. In the meet-and-greet, this person, X, thanked us for the talk. X looked familiar but we couldn’t place it.

X then said, “You’ve written about me.” It clicked.

X then expressed a most welcome thought: “You are much different than I thought or expected.” In so many words, “You’re not the monster some people say.” In other words, X had discovered the actual person, that kind, considerate, articulate fellow–well met and gentle.

X took the trouble to get to know the chap rather than ignorantly stumble around believing the wild tales and myths about who we are, how we are connected, and how we love kicking canes from under old ladies crossing North Street by Newberry’s.

———- ooo ———-

This happens all the time for public figures. Too many people confuse what they see and hear for the reality. They mistake “persona” for “the person.” This think the performances are the predictors of the actual person.

Does that mean THE PLANET isn’t sincere in our opinions and commentaries? Not at all.  Truth in commentary subsists independently of the vehicle of delivery. We offer this blog as a public service to (a) inform (b) get people to think and (c) stimulate public debate.

This experiment in median comes with the luxury of unilateral control, no councils or committees hindering us with the tarpit of bureaucracy. The words we write and speak stand on their own. We will have it no other way. When confronted by a hothead, we often shock by (get ready for this) ACTUALLY LISTENING TO WHAT THEY HAVE TO SAY. They expect a waylay, but they get a hearing.

THE PLANET is a provocateur and a polemicist. We can argue both sides of any argument that has a reasonable “both sides.” For example, we would not want to make the case for tiny TV sets being planted in asphalt to secretly monitor citizens, but if you took a contentious issue such as the death penalty or abortion, we could take–AND WIN–both sides.

We did this once in debate. At Union College, on successive weeks we argued the yeah and neah sides of the same issue against students from Colgate and Cornell on “Resolved: Students should be allowed to skip class without penalty and shut down a school building in peaceful protest [against the Vietnam War].” We won both times case.  Oh yeah, and we shook hands after and went to the Rathskeller for pitchers of golden lager. We didn’t cancel anyone. No one screamed or shouted anyone down. No one got violent. We were young adults back then, and we knew how to c-o-n-v-e-r-s-e.

———- ooo ———-

In Massachusetts, citizens labor under a government that’s 90% radical left-loon Democrat. Predictably, this form of totalitarian rule has imposed a wanton ideology upon its overtaxed, underserved middle class. Poisonous identity politics have replaced merit and worth when it comes to filling positions and making policy. The results speak for themselves both at the state and city levels, or do you think something monstrous like the dreadful Two-Pete Government would EVER stand a chance at winning an election in anything other than a rigged game?

If, however, the Bay State had a 90% hard right government, we would be presenting the other side, all to fight against the imposed rule of one-party, unimaginative, bureaucratic apparatchiks.

Fact is, you will never know what lies within our heart … unless you ask, privately, in a place and at a time where we can conduct intimate dialogue. The only weapon you’ll need is your intellect.

Such a thing can still be done. You only need two willing parties closed to the ignorance of cancel culture and open to the free exchange of ideas.

THE PLANET always remains willing.

—————————————————————-

One time’s a fluke. Two is a trend. Three times is a pattern” — Sir Donald Turpentine, Knight of the Bath.

“OPEN THE WINDOW, AUNT MILLIE.”

LOVE TO ALL.

Copyright (c) 2025 By Dan Valenti, PLANET VALENTI and EUROPOLIS MANAGEMENT. All rights reserved. The views and opinions expressed in the comment section or in the text other than those of PLANET VALENTI are not necessarily endorsed by the operators of this website. PLANET VALENTI assumes no responsibility for such views and opinions, and it reserves the right to remove or edit any comment, including but not limited to those that violate the website’s Rules of Conduct and its editorial policies. Those who leave comments own all the responsibilities that are or can be attached to those comments, be they rhetorical, semantic, or legal. Such commentators remain solely responsible for what they post and shall be and remain solely accountable for their words. PLANET VALENTI shall not be held responsible for the consequences that may result from any posted comment or outside opinion or commentary as provided in, but not limited to, Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act and this website’s terms of service. We serve as a marketplace of ideas, without prejudice and available to all. All users of this site — including readers, commentators, contributors, or anyone else — hereby agree to these conditions by virtue of this notice and their use of/participation in this site. When PLANET VALENTI ends with the words “The Usual Disclaimer,” that phrase shall be understood to refer to the full text of this disclaimer.

5 2 votes
Article Rating
24 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jonathan A. Melle
Jonathan A. Melle
1 month ago

I would like Dan Valenti to moderate the debates for Pittsfield City Council and School Committee prior to the November 04th, 2025, municipal election, please.

Please ask the candidates if they believe that Mayor Peter Marchetti has been an effective leader? Who has he helped (other than himself, Kufflinks, etc.)? Who has he hurt (other than the taxpayers)?

Please ask them about the Level 5 (failed), Group 11 (underclass) public school district that close to 700 students choice out of to neighboring public school districts?

There are so many questions up for debate for the voters to hear about in Pittsfield politics. But the problem is that the debate moderator(s), news media outlets, and most of the blogs won’t ask the difficult to address questions to the candidates.

Sarcasm: A master debater knows that the government is supposed to serve the people and taxpayers well, while a masturbator takes matters into his own hand for his own satisfaction.

Jonathan A. Melle
Jonathan A. Melle
Reply to  danvalenti
1 month ago

The Berkshire Museum is back in the news again….

“Berkshire Museum chief curator says he was fired after making complaints about executive director”
By Jennifer Huberdeau, The Berkshire Eagle, September 24, 2025

PITTSFIELD — The chief curator of the Berkshire Museum said he was fired on Monday[, September 22nd].

Jesse Kowalski, who was in the process of curating an exhibition about the Holocaust and antisemitism set to open in spring 2027, said in an interview with The Eagle on Tuesday[, September 23rd,] that he was fired for “unprofessional behavior and damage to the museum.”

http://www.berkshireeagle.com/news/central_berkshires/berkshire-museum-curator-fired/article_ea40a549-9790-4fab-94f4-b0fbbd738d87.html

AWAY: as been lost.
AWAY: as been lost.
Reply to  danvalenti
1 month ago

The problem, and big one, is Pittsfield

Jon Melle
Jon Melle
Reply to  AWAY: as been lost.
1 month ago

We pay a lot of money for Pittsfield politics being the problem!

ShirleyKnutz
ShirleyKnutz
Reply to  Jon Melle
1 month ago

When was the last time you paid taxes in Pittsfield??? I believe you meant to say the poor taxpayers of Pittsfield pay alot of money for the privilege to live in a $$$$hiiiiiit pile!!

Pisstulle Pete
Pisstulle Pete
Reply to  Jonathan A. Melle
1 month ago

Who by the way is responsible for the water department?

Eric Swansin
Eric Swansin
Reply to  Pisstulle Pete
1 month ago

I believe Jonny’s fellow swordsman CC President Pete White oversees it. You could always call and ask him unless he’s deeply involved in an epic sword fight as Jonny and Pete always say the bigger the sword the better the battle.

The school committee
The school committee
1 month ago

The radical right wing just telivised a hate filled funeral of a internet streamer that was used by our fascist leader to create a distraction from project 2025 and as Musk reported that Trump is all over the Epstien file.Lets blog about the release of that file about the abuse and manipulation of at least 1000 children.Trump is clearly not well with crazy rambling at the UN calling the civilized people failed….Putin Netanyahu Kim Jung Un and Orban own this crime ridden administration and you boys love his baby talk he gives you to relax you all into submission.Release the Epstien file.

Optimus Prime
Optimus Prime
Reply to  The school committee
1 month ago

The clowns with TDS like TSC revel in ignorance, because to venture outside of it risks the collapse of their
entire worldview.

Meanwhile
Meanwhile
Reply to  The school committee
1 month ago

Is someone trying to incite a civil war?

Fari question.

The school committee
The school committee
Reply to  Meanwhile
1 month ago

Miller and Trump

Pisstulle Pete
Pisstulle Pete
Reply to  The school committee
1 month ago

Supposedly there was an uptick in legionella this past summer, higher levels….. The was was treated I guess and everything was all right, the newest thing at the hospital with legionella the mayor claims there’s no legionella right now and it’s not coming from the city’s water system? Is he an expert.

Why doesn’t the water commissioner or the health department say anything?. Is this before during or a while ago when they treated it with higher chlorine levels.

Did the latest water report or the latest water report from the summers legionella increase on the report. There were several people that I know that were sick this summer. Let’s expect some answers.

Sir Chaz
Sir Chaz
Reply to  Pisstulle Pete
1 month ago

Legionnaires would likely thrive in HVAC systems. Stagnate water. Be odd the start looking at the treatment plant which is agitating and treating water.

Markus Aurelius
Markus Aurelius
Reply to  Sir Chaz
1 month ago

At the cost of $70,000,000 for Bitchfield taxpayers less than 3 years ago, you would like to think it’s not the treatment plant, but this Bitchfield after all.

Bump outs, African paid vacations, and the taxpayer paid/government hidden PHS pedophile report, take priority over taxpayers.

It’s a page taken right out of the MA Illegal Aliens State Rep. Tricia Farley-Country Buffet (d-illegal aliens), taking care of your special interests’ playbook.

https://www.berkshireeagle.com/news/central_berkshires/pittsfield-70-million-dollar-wastewater-treatment-plant-upgrade/article_69e31024-8df2-11ed-9398-fbe6451131c6.html

Somebody asked above who was running the treatment plant. May I suggest to that person learning how to perform a simple google search to try and answer your own question.

I did it for you this time. It’s Carl Shaw.

https://www.pittsfieldma.gov/601/Wastewater

ShirleyKnutz
ShirleyKnutz
Reply to  The school committee
1 month ago

Dan I hate to say this but the brainwashed socialist/communist dumbocrats who live in “The Beeeerkshires” are so closed minded that no one can open up their pea brains to have a civil discussion with them. All they know how to do is be infantile by name calling a screaming. Just ask them for specifics on any topic and their eyes are glazed over and the start muttering like the great autopen of years past while drooling down the front of their shirts.

Tom Betit
Tom Betit
1 month ago

Dan
After criticizing District attorneys office , for denial of equal protections , after suffering a premeditated assault and act of mayhem.

Instead of ” two willing parties closed to the ignorance of cancel culture and open to the free exchange of ideas.” Candidate Caccaviello perpetrated a retaliatory false arrest, after no trespassing , a complainant from the District attorneys office. count 1

To protect a judicially protected criminal
, from prosecution. Sound familiar ? Count 2

Your colleague Aidan “Turtleboy” Kearney , is suffering the same politically perpetrated conspiracy to intimidate a witness ,count 3

Violation of civil rights, under color of law count 4

Fortunately Fredick Rothberg , felt entitled to use his propaganda parrot, to defame myself, and continue the conspiracy. Count 5 -7

It gets worse, including Maura Healey’s jilted lover Justice Dalila Argaez Wendlandt , denial of my ^th amendment due process civil rights -SJ-2024-0455- Wendlandt is so judicially illiterate, she feels entitled to violate my due process civil right to a fair trial
“at odds with more than two centuries’ worth of precedent, not to mention the Constitution itself”
Counts 7-12

The commonwealth has finally submitted as I,m a bit hard to intimidate , their last effort , June 27, 2025 with Lt Ryan Dickinson (MSP Berkshire district attorneys office ) and MSP Lt Colonel (defectives) Daniel Tucker ( brother of Essex District Attorney Paul F. Tucker ) nepotism and patronage was former federal prosecutor Paul Smyths mandate, he chose to Use his position to provide White supremist Hoaxes ” Springfield Church arson 2008″ he used Honey pot to encourage 3 dummies to commit crime.
Providing Odumber with sympathy vote in 2008 election. In 2019 he framed “Dalton hay bale arsonist ”
With assistance of Propagandist Andrew McKeevers (Nipples press secretary) brother providing the incriminating statements , followed by Da administrative assistants husbands corroboration. as only evidence, then eliciting an inadmissible confession from a drunk patsy . When the false Unabomber case against myself fell apart, due to obvious framing. then 5 more attempts Timmy Shitgrew wisely avoided, knowing , i don’t plead, intimidate or frighten, but do get many of his cases dismissed as a jailhouse lawyer. counts 12-20

Interested in sitting in on an interview with Timmy and Dickinson-to hear their explanation to the above accusations? Time to make some more news, we will get the government we deserve, only if we work for it. Plus the Berkshires needs our Turtleboyesq muckraker back!

Tom
9/24/25/@ 1:50 pm

Tom Betit
Tom Betit
Reply to  danvalenti
28 days ago

Dan
Alan Jackson will be giving MSP Including Lt Col Dan Tucker a Hy Colonic , that will empty MSP unions and Trial courts coffers. If Moron Stealy , is upset with the big beautiful bills 650,000,000 $ deduction, wait till the Billion two court , public pretenders 750,000,000$ , and public safety 15,000,000$ reimbursements hit!
Its not like MAGA will lose any votes, Imagine the oval office laughter when Russ Vought eliminated 15 Billion $ from New York transportation reimbursements today:)
Shutdown Schumer got played by MAGA like ignorant immatures . What chance does Moron Stealy have? LOL

Politics is a fast ,high stakes and dangerous game, Fraudsters, fakes and fools get crushed, and now prosecuted! Taxatwoshits is low hanging fruit, thankfully US District courts will be uncorrupted soon thanks to Wild Bill Young’s unhinged judicial rant. While attempting to protect Harvard’s newest crop of Palestinian Sirhan Sirhan jihadist, professors and students.

Even Governor Hair Gel , understood , codling Jihadis is poor political policy.

Bill after getting bench slapped by Gorsuch and Kavanaugh, chose to double down on judicial imperialism, with a side of unabashed political propaganda. Typical demonrat had a temper tantrum, when things don’t go his way!

Wild Bill at 85, should of been put out to pasture 40 years ago, Another Reagan mistake, how anyone feels he was a good president, bogles the mind. Autopen wasn’t Americas first, incoherent misleader and thief .

Look for federal investigation to be unsealed soon, Meatball Morrisey will have allot of fellow prosecutors for company in prison.

So when do you want to schedule interview ? Perhaps a public venue, Berkshire Atheneum ?

Tom
10/1/25 @ 3:30pm

Jonathan A. Melle
Jonathan A. Melle
1 month ago

They are changing the RULES of Pittsfield politics because the 2-Pete system needs upgrades….

https://www.iberkshires.com/story/80376/Pittsfield-Council-Drops-Mayor-as-School-Chair-Change.html

Mr. Fritz
Mr. Fritz
1 month ago

Dementia Joe, the autopen president……

https://www.zerohedge.com/political/trumps-best-troll-ever

The school committee
The school committee
1 month ago

Does anyone feel that Bondi will release the pediphile files.

Markus Aurelius
Markus Aurelius
1 month ago

Here is a 90 second clip describing “Stochastic Terrorism.” If you pay attention, you will see it’s the exact same methods being used by today’s democRAT party, just like Hitler did in WWII to the Jews.

Joseph Goebbels would be proud of today’s democRATS.

Dehumanize them (calling MAGA members Nazi’s), eliminate them (Charlie Kirk), and silence them through fear (cancel culture).

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DOjeTWDkr4s/?igsh=YjllNXNweWQxd29i

ShirleyKnutz
ShirleyKnutz
Reply to  Markus Aurelius
1 month ago

The Dems love the Orwellian system of changing the meanings of words and playing on the citizens fear