HANDICAPPING, AND WE MEAN HANDICAPPING, THE “RACE” for DISTRICT ATTORNEY
BY DAN VALENTI
PLANET VALENTI NEWS AND COMMENTARY
(FORTRESS OF SOLITUDE, WEDNESDAY JULY 18, 2018) — Making sense of the stillborn race for District Attorney is rather like explaining Russia: No matter what you say about it is true. Even if it’s false, it will somehow be true. THE PLANET calls the race “stillborn” because it involves one party only: Democrats. That should come as no surprise in a county and Commonwealth that runs on a single-party system. … you know, like the Soviet Union circa Cold War. In Massachusetts, you’re a Democrat or you’re nobody. And give me no Charlie Baker, that de facto Dem. He typically would be the exception that proves the rule, but he’s a stooge of a rule that allows no exceptions, even for — ahem — alleged “Republicans.”
The three contestants line up this way. There’s the heavy favorite, current DA by coronation Paul Caccaviello; yet-again Andrea Harrington; and Judith Knight.
Caccaviello’s claim on the job will be his years in the county DA’s office, that long line of royalty that goes unbroken before Tony Ruberto, then Gerry Downing, David Capeless, and now, after Capeless mysteriously bailed out of his term 10 months early, his hand-picked successor, Caccaviello. Cacc made the most noise in the dead-to-date campaign with Wifegate, a tawdry affair in which his wife and Capeless’s got into a spitting match with the owner of Otto’s Grease Joint at East and Wendell Avenue Extension after the latter posted nasty things about “her man” on his Fakebook page. Just for laughs, Alan Harris, owner of Berkshire Money Management and his sponsoree, John Krol of The John Krol Show, joined the fun.
Can you tell we’re in Pittsfield, yet?
Wifegate, a moniker put on the profumo affair by our good friend Mike Ward, is likely the closest thing that this campaign will see to a debate of “the issues.” And wait until the September primary. Turnout will be so low that it will be looking up at the earthworms in Pittsfield Cemetery.
Yet Again Harrington shows up for office as frequently as Donna Todd Rivers flips her flop and sells out to the highest bidder. Harrington’s previous run came against Sen. Adam Chrome Dome, D-Nowhere. Her platform consisted of the hope that another senator named Andrea would be took much for voters to resist. She had no chance, alack, since she found herself up against The Machine, the same one she faces in this race. The Machine has shown a few cracks, a symptom of which had to be Capeless’s premature exit, leading sleuths to wonder in unison, “Hmmmm.” Add to that the general discontent with incumbents, and anything’s possible.
THE PLANET will not make any endorsements in this race, but we will tell you to stay well away from any candidate who talks about her “holistic” view of the law. That’s Harrington’s great vision for the top criminal justice official in Berkshire County. Holistic. That’s code for: We will be weak on crime. These poor people need our understanding, a boost up, methadone, and public handouts. They’re not criminals. They’re victims of white, male, middle-class imperialism.
In an earlier interview with our friend and colleague Terry Cowgill of The Edge, Yet Again claimed she had “a 7,000-foot view of the criminal justice system.” She forgot to mention that she has no experience whatsoever as a prosecutor, leading THE PLANET to think that “7,000-foot view” came after being thrown out of a Cessna without a parachute. With every second, the ground comes closer, and along the way between now and the September primary, Yet Again will be heard shouting, “So far, so good.” We can’t say if she’ll finish second or third (our money is on Place), but we do know what her final campaign utterance will be: “Splat!!”
This brings us to attorney Judith Knight. This woman at least brings experience to the table in the form of her service as assistant district attorney of Middlesex County. That’s Boston way, so she knows her way around the big city. Knight’s chief problem will be visibility. She’s only known through her lawn signs, and not only do lawn signs not vote, they do not create news. Incidentally, “lawn signs do not vote” must pass as political wisdom. This is, in case you forgot, “The Berkshires.” God help us. We must also observe that Knight and Yet Again split the anti-incumbent vote. Game. Set. Match.
With all that, THE PLANET can map out the winning strategy for each candidate:
Caccaviello: Avoid debates, keep a low profile, put a gag in the wives’ mouths, and above all, “energize the base,” which is to say, don’t do anything to make The Machine mad. Heavy favorite.
Harrington: Make a lot of noise. Challenge Cacc at every turn. Call him out. Put all you’ve got in Pittsfield. Forget the rest of the county. The county seat alone will decide this race. Take Pittsfield and you become the next DA. She’s got a decent start on outer West Street and Valentine Road with a cancerous multiplication of lawn signs. Now she must follow that up by somehow getting Caccaviello in sight from hiding. Long shot.
Same with Knight. Get visible. Somehow gets voters interested. Match your experience with Cacc’s. Make some news. Longer shot.
There might be one other tactic that would greatly improve the odds for either woman: It goes by the code name “Operation Bernie Baron.” Ah, but we guess not one of them would dare dare dare touch that third rail. It would only be the biggest local story of the past and current century.
——————————————————————
You can’t take from your mind what you don’t have in it” — Sir Tiberius Fruitjuice.
OPEN THE WINDOW, AUNT MILLIE.”
LOVE TO ALL.
The views and opinions expressed in the comment section or in the text other than those of PLANET VALENTI are not necessarily endorsed by the operators of this website. PLANET VALENTI assumes no responsibility for such views and opinions, and it reserves the right to remove or edit any comment, including but not limited to those that violate the website’s Rules of Conduct and its editorial policies. PLANET VALENTI shall not be held responsible for the consequences that may result from any posted comment or outside opinion or commentary as provided in Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act and this website’s terms of service. All users of this website — including readers, commentators, contributors, or anyone else making use of its information hereby agree to these conditions by virtue of this notice. When PLANET VALENTI ends with the words “The Usual Disclaimer,” that phrase shall be understood to refer to the full text of this disclaimer.
Fake Krol and Baffled Barry are pushing Harrington. That alone should disqualify her in most voter’s minds. And to top it off I just saw a picture of her and stink breath Ruberto on Facebook.
Harrington is a joke backed by Krol and clueless Clairmont.
Planet must have some thoughts on Trump treasonist act?More important than John Kroll wanting to be Harringtons spokesmen for the Berkshires DA.
Can you just give it a rest for a while?
Trump, best POTUS since Reagan. Long Live The Republic.
Anyone not get garbage picked up today?
Trump is the Chris Columbus of Pittsfield.
Caccaviello came after Baran went up the river for life, but Ford is still a judge and Ford was the prosecutor.
Caccviello’s challengers will split the women vote as well as the liberal looney tune vote.
Harrington is a joke as is Knight and they both want to play nice with the ganagbangers and oher dirt bags because drug dealers are only “non violent drug offenders” who are supporting their habit.
Can someone please enlighten me by providing a link or some detail,about this wifegatenthing?
Harrington’s husband is going around bullying West Stockbridge store owners to take down their Caccaviello signs but of course the misogynistic BB doesn’t write about that.
Maybe the BB doesn’t write about it because it’s hearsay. The DA ladies documented their bullying on answering machines and midnight text messages.
Turk
Exactly!!
Good point, their inability to actually go out and find out anything for themselves vs transcribe he said she said is just one of the things that makes them a doomed rag of yesteryear.
The last I read about it, the District Attorney position pays over $170,000 per year. Like other criminal justice positions, it pay$ to be politically-connected. The best part of the deal is the future pension. If it weren’t for criminals, the well taken care of bureaucrats would be out of their high paying jobs!
I also wonder who will benefit the most by low voter turnout on September 4th?
There is also a Democratic Primary between moderate Congressman Richie Neal and liberal challenger Tahira Amadul-Wadud.
I remember a very long time ago when a teenager from Great Barrington was being railroaded into jail for selling pot in a school zone. An over zealous district attorney for whatever reason wanted this kid in jail. And I seem to remember Judy Knight defending the kid saying how ridiculous it was to put a high school kid in jail for the 2 year mandatory sentence for selling pot.
So for this act of humanity she certainly gets my serious consideration while anyone who is part of the Pittsfield machine does not. There is too much concentrated power in Pittsfield and while my one little vote may not change that, I have to do it for my conscious. .
You’re leaving out of that story the fact that the kid refused to cooperate on the brilliant advise of Knight (as did her other client who was busted again weeks later). The thing was a decade ago, thousands of young adults go thru the DAs office annually with no sweat. But she regurgitates this one. Oh and you might mention her “prosecution” experience was as a junior ada 25 years ago.
I was actually afraid to make my comment as I knew it might draw a hit from the machine
but still, I no longer vote for machine candidates who seem to control every powerful office in the city
And Harrington isn’t a machine candidate? Fake Krol and Crooked Clairmont are her two biggest backers.
They’re all machine candidates. Every last one of them.
You are so right dusty.
I am with you!!!
Garbage pickup has been missed in several areas of the city. The reason given is lack of manpower.
And the mayor recently signed a 5 yr. contract with Republic?
So much for that wisdom!
The garbage situation has “disaster” written all over it. That five year deal has the redolence of a stink bomb.
I agree, Dan. And am I correct that this contract was never presented to our CC to be rubber stamped?
I guess we don’t have “checks and balances” in this city.
Its bothersome for the few of us who do go the polls to see the candidate quit 10 months early. Mr. Capeless was elected for 4 years. It’s probable that Mr. Caccaviello will be elected and then re-elected. In 8 years he’ll be 65. Can we assume that in 7 years and 2 months he’ll be stepping aside for his minion?
I agree, TM. To bail out crushes what little is left of the “democratic” system. Capeless gets to appoint his successor, and the coronation continues.
I guess I would ask, who would you want representing you if your daughter was shot and killed and witnesses refused to cooperate? Harrington, who has never prosecuted a single case and the very few she did defend were DUIs etc (by the way, ask how those went. She cried to the judge and asked to be removed from one of those cases because she was in her own words “incompetent” due to her being too involved in the campaign for Senate.) Or Knight, who has never exhibited an ounce of interest in crime prevention, addiction treatment, children services in fact any social causes at all or anything other than handling a few cases and failing in a run for DA on the “soft on crime” platform. You can rage against the machine all you want, but at the end of the day if there are more drug dealers, more shootings, more crime in Pittsfield you have no one to blame but yourself if you don’t show up Sept. 4 and vote for Caccaviello.
Capeless will hang on foru finished cases like pot dealers,and such.
If Krol is supporting Harrington I’m voting for Cacc. Krol is all that is wrong with politics – hangs around too long, never gives back and sucks every morsel of marrow out of anything he can find – oh and he manipulates the elderly shamelessly –
Krol will end up like Marchetti. Average .
Three more pot stores moving to Pittsfield. This is very sad since for some people pot is a gateway drug according to a local doctor who treats drug addiction.
The gateway drug theory has been disproved a thousand times over. The number one gateway drug is alcohol, which has caused more problems in this city than pot will in a hundred years. The only reason doctors lobby against marijuana (smoking notwithstanding) is that its users have much less need to go to them because their low stress levels mean less ailments. It’s a money loser for the AMA and big pharma.
Not all stress is bad. Some stress is actually good motivation to get things done. There are many other ways to relax without putting all kinds of substances in your body.
Pittsfield, MA – home of the druggies. This ‘city’ continues its downward spiral.
Today is the 49 anniversary of the druken hero of Chappaquiddick killing Mary Jo. I hope the low life Kennedy family is having a good day.
I am just reading the book Chappaquiddick by Leo Damore. I highly recommend it. There are a lot of details about it that I never knew.
17 phone calls… That’s how many times Ted Kennedy picked up the phone before he called the police to report the car accident that resulted in Mary Jo Kopechne’s death.
Today is the 49th anniversary of the famous midnight swim of the “Liberal Lion,” or should I say, “Lyin’,” considering his contradictory, unbelievable, perjurious descriptions of how his brother’s 28-year-old secretary suffocated in the backseat of his mother’s 1967 Oldsmobile Delmont at the bottom of a tidal pond on Martha’s Vineyard.
Glad to see someone else subscribes to Howie Carr – best show on radio.
Too bad Berkshire County radio station 1420 no longer carries the Howie Carr show…..I wonder why.
IHeartRadio WHYN on your internet “dial”
Pittsfield radio really sucks. Go to iHeartRadio and listen to 56 WHYN and listen to Howie Carr . Your eyes will be opened.
Please don’t. Pat doesn’t need any more indoctrination.
Gaetani News Hour tonight 6 p m. Bethere at Channel 1301 for the best show on PCTV. All Call ins welcome.
We have to many regressive lawyers in the Senate.They are making America great again aligning themselves with Russia and telling our allies to go to hell a disgrace to every war veteran. Trump is making Russia great again…..Pat loves Russia because they have a economy about the size of New York State and They wanted Trump to break with Europe
incoherent imbecile
Trump will build hotels in Russia paid for by the Russian government… would???? Or wouldn’t,you?
DA may have interesting case coming his way. Shooting in Pittsfield
The lovely Linda Tyer is the best Mayor of Pittsfield EVER!
Do you have a linda shrine in the backyard?
Don’t hurt yourself admiring her
Melle- clearly you don’t live here…LT is the biggest disappointment as Mayor – she kept no campaign promises – a wasted 4 years…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-VEHYZknuKE
Trump supporters are living proof of a failed American education system.
Progressive politics supporters are proof that critical thinking skills are no longer taught in the American education system. If we had critical thinking skills in modern classrooms we wouldn’t have people wanting to abolish ICE because they think it’s a terrorist organization. They would be able to think logically and realize we need to protect our borders and in these dangerous times we can’t have open borders. They would realize that not all children who come to the border are with people who are really their parents and we need to do DNA tests to confirm if there is a relationship to prevent further harm to the children.
Critical thinkers would realize that socialism doesn’t work and only leads to disaster. The list goes on and on……….
Trump Apologists’ Disorder
Critical thinkers don’t kiss KGB agents asses.
jus sayin
You mean like when Obama told Russia he’d have more flexibility after the election? Or his order to stop the US cyber chief from taking any action against the 2016 election interference. Or “We think there’s an excellent opportunity to put US-Russian relations on a much stronger footing,” Obama said.
Or how about Clinton: Clinton and Putin shake hands July 22, 2000 before the start of a meeting during the Group of Eight (G8) economic summit in Nago, Japan. Clinton shares a light moment with Putin before a Group of Eight meeting in Nago, Okinawa, Japan
Or Bush? Bush shakes hands with Putin in the garden of the Brdo Castle near Ljubljana, Slovenia on June 16, 2001 for a summit meeting.”He’s a man deeply committed to his country and the best interests of his country, and I appreciate very much the frank dialogue and that’s the beginning of a very constructive relationship,” Bush said of Putin.
Gee, I was hoping the planet could moderate a debate on the DA race, would be a lot more informative and lopsided than the Berkshire Brigades, 4 Freedoms, excuses for anything meaningful.
Pittsfield cop’s house riddled with bullets in broad daylight….retaliation from an arrest? Pittsfield just went from bad to off the charts…sorry but this one effects everybody
How can there be no danger to the public, which is what they’re reporting, if the house is riddled with bullets? Unless they know specifically that this is some form of retaliation then someone is going around shooting at houses? None of the articles I have read even mention the bullets in the house.
and that is one reason this story should be taken with a grain of stool until it is backed up with facts
Could also be Dusty that we get less and less info from local news media.
iberkshire now saying it was a self inflicted gunshot
Dusty, that’s why I paid no attention to Rocky Creed’s bullshit about the house being riddled with bullets.
Downright stupid to post shit like that.
How can neighborhood be safe when they don’t know what happened to begin with.
Let’s not forget the new DA already has at least 2 high-profile murder cases, locally, to prosecute. The death of a 22-year-old girl who was shot in the head as a bystander to an act of violence between adults. And what appears to be a more calculated murder of a man in a park on the Fourth of July.
Here’s an interesting story about the former DA. As the family of the slain girl was preparing her body for her private funeral, they were kicked out of the room in the funeral parlor to allow prisoner Christopher Davis to have a private goodbye with his alleged girlfriend. At the time Davis was being held at the BCHC, without the right to bail, pending a dangerousness hearing. Neither the parents nor any of the family of the murdered child was asked for permission for this to happen, or even made aware until the Sheriff showed up at the funeral home with the prisoner and told the family members to leave while he said his goodbye. This egregious violation was sanctioned by the DA and the sheriffs office, with zero respect for the family in an excruciating time of grief.
Here’s the kicker – Davis was granted this special permission by way of an agreement with the DAs office. He agreed to testify at grand jury in the murder case of James Dominguez, who was shot in the head and murdered outside a local bar the year before. Some readers here may remember the grand announcement made in the murder case of JD. Suspect charged! Hooray!
A few weeks later you may also recall an article regarding the prosecution of Christopher Davis for lying to a grand jury in a capital murder case. What the police and DA didn’t tell the public was that Davis lied to the grand jury, he received an unpermitted and unwelcome special private visit with the murder victim to be the first person to say goodbye to her. Yanna’s funeral was a private service with family only, who wanted to express their grief prior to opening up the parlor to the public. Instead, they spent their last days with her, knowing that their privacy and respect and decent humanity had been violated by the sheriffs office, the district attorney, and the funeral parlor as well for allowing this to happen.
And the murder of James Dominguez? You never heard anything more about that, right? That’s because they had to release the suspect they had charged with his murder based on the false testimony of Davis. But you didn’t see that in the newspaper.
Just another dead person for that new DA to tend with…
That’s quite the story. Where are the facts to prove what you are saying?
Well, I know the family personally. That’s how I know.
And you can also read a brief reference to the ordeal in the following article.
https://www.berkshireeagle.com/stories/life-a-nightmare-for-asiyanna-jones-parents-while-pushing-for-justice-after-daughters-killing,544818
Almost unbelievable right? It’s all completely true.
See also:
https://www.berkshireeagle.com/stories/pittsfield-mans-bail-revoked-in-drug-case-200k-bail-set-for-allegedly-lying-to-grand-jury,527937
I don’t know where you’ve gotten this story from Auto Phil but the DA was not involved with Davis going to the funeral home and only learned of it after.
John, I think you’d be hard-pressed to find anyone who actually believed that. It would be pretty hard to believe that Davis struck a deal with the Sheriff, agreeing to testify in a murder case that resulted in the DA charging someone with first degree murder, without the DA actually knowing before hand.
Good post Auto Phil. Something that drives me nuts with the DA’s office is the constant dismissal of weapons and ammunition charges. All we ever here these days is we need more gun laws and this office never enforce the ones we have. What ever happened to the mandatory jail time that we use to post signs when entering the state. Law abiding citizens have to jump through hoops and spend a lot of money to legally possess firearms. Why? Nothing happens to those who do not follow the laws.
Hell, they even drop the stolen gun charges. Do they even ask the victim of the theft how they feel? I think not. I am willing to bet that if a decent law abiding citizen got stopped and their permit was 1 day expired they would get hung out to dry.
Hear
Gingrich sums this all up very well and most accurately.
“Whatever the Russians did, they did while Brennan was director of the CIA, Clapper was director of national intelligence, and James Comey was head of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. These former officials attack Trump ferociously to hide their own failure and their own guilt.”
And don’t forget that this all happened while Obama was president.
Don’t forget about Hillary. Hannity’s book says that every time you need to pivot from a bad Trump headline you must mention Hillary as well as Obama. I think it might even be a law.
Sure. Let’s mention Hillary who was selling uranium to Russia. It was all beautiful for the Dems.
Hillary has her own list of failures, including finding a way to lose an already won presidential election, but she was no longer Sec of State when all the 2016 meddling went on. Obama and his cronies get the blame for that one.
dusty. thanks for your daily delusion.
What the liberal Dems are doing to this country and our own state. The city of San Francisco this week began allowing non-citizens, including illegal immigrants, to register to vote in the November election for the city school board.
“We want to give immigrants the right to vote,” Supervisor Norman Yee told KGO.
A similar initiative of giving limited voting rights has also reportedly been approved in Chicago and multiple cities in Maryland and Massachusetts.
Voting rights for illegals is so disgusting.
It’s just the start. The next step is to give them full voting rights. It’s part of the plan by the liberals to get as many votes as possible. They’ve already done a great job getting the MS-13 vote.
True. How dare we say the violence of MS-13 makes them animals when these are future voters for the Progressives.
Tyer should be out yesterday with a statement that she is on the scene,this might be the biggest crime story in the country right now.Shooting at the residents of a Police officer.Never heard of this before.
It’s Obamas fault ,got it and have it your way.Now shall we continue with the investigation…Iknow I know no collusion OK OK Trump did nothing.So the investigation is taking place with Trump in office.Why can’t we find out what went on,I do not understand your fear of Mueller.
I love the new time cover where Trump morphs into Putin. That is the stark reality we are facing today.
And you wonder why we call fake news
There is no reality from liberal rags like Time.
No evidence of collusion, nor will any be found. The investigation is being purposely dragged out until the mid term elections are over.
The only evidence of Russian collusion was the Clinton campaign procuring the fake dossier from them on Trump.
President Trump starting a job training program for all ages. I have been pleading for government to do this since the 2008 housing crash killed the economy. Very smart idea and much needed!!!!
Sounds like a good program. Now let’s sit back and listen to all the delusional hateful liberals say why it’s such a bad idea.
If Trump cured cancer they’d complain that it would take away jobs from oncologists.
Trump will not cure cancer. Trump IS cancer.
If trump wasn’t such a pompous pig, he still would be a incorrigible,self indulgent fool. Again to repeat another, the people who support Trump ,verifies that our education system his failing in our Country.
also shows how easy it is to form a cult
You need a Laxative.
Flip Flop better understand that her show is way inferior to to most of the shows on PCTV. It might be better than maybe a couple, but it is nowhere near the show that is by far most popular, Gaetani News Hour, clearly the best Show on PCTV.
In the coming weeks we will see what the GMan has in store for the E P A director ( bring a diaper) as Gaetani plans on a full scale assault on the departure of the unneeded and costly water-sewer pig-swallow to the taxpayers.
Wow!
The all knowing PV members respond to an article of a copper’s house being “riddled with bullets” when it was a SI/GSW.
An “inside job” so to speak. Read between the lines FCS!
This why I take PV respondents with a grain of salt. Piss on all of you. Fake news, rumor mongers, assholes and anybody that looks like you!
Let’s hope 1st, mental health issues are taken care of with the SIGS Victim and #2 justice is served and the PO involved had secured his weapons and/or the Victim had an LTC.
People need to trust in their LE professionals when they say “no danger to the public.”